Question about OBE, dreaming and death

istvan_06

A Disturbance in the Force
Hello Friends,

I have two question:
1. What is the Fourth way saying about the Out of Body Experiences? A read a lot of success stories regarding to it. Those people all have got a soul? How can be so many self created soul? Or what is projecting out of the body?

Osha said Gurdjieff lying:
http://www.osho.com/read/osho/osho-on-topics/george-gurdjieff
"Gurdjieff said, “You are nothing but the body, and when the body dies you will die. Only once in a while does a person survive – one who has created soul in his life survives death – not all. A Buddha survives; a Jesus survives, but not you! You will simply die, not even a trace will be left.”

What was Gurdjieff trying to do? He was shocking you to the very roots; he was trying to take away all your consolations and foolish theories which go on helping you to postpone work upon yourself. Now, to tell people, “You don’t have any souls, you are just vegetables, just a cabbage or maybe a cauliflower” – a cauliflower is a cabbage with a college education – “but nothing more than that.” He was really a master par excellence. He was taking the very earth away from underneath your feet. He was giving you such a shock that you had to think over the whole situation: are you going to remain a cabbage? He was creating a situation around you in which you would have to seek and search for the soul, because who wants to die?

And the idea that the soul is immortal has helped people to console themselves that they are not going to die, that death is just an appearance, just a long sleep, a restful sleep, and you will be born again. Gurdjieff says, “All nonsense. This is all nonsense! Dead, you are dead forever – unless you have created the soul….”

Now see the difference: you have been told you are already a soul, and Gurdjieff changes it totally. He says, “You are not already a soul, but only an opportunity. You can use it, you can miss it.”

And I would like to tell you that Gurdjieff was just using a device. It is not true. Everybody is born with a soul. But what to do with people who have been using truths as consolations? A great master sometimes has to lie – and only a great master has the right to lie – just to pull you out of your sleep.

Osho, The Dhammapada: The Way of the Buddha, Vol. 2, Talk #2"

There is another solution. The OBE is an imagination and not truth. What do you think about it?
I tried OBE many times but never happend to me...

2. If a man sleeps what happend to him? I read about that the links between centers are disconnected for a sleeping time. In what center are we then? Instinctive? If I use self remembering why do not get myself full conscious during sleep? And what will be a different when i will die? What will bring me conscious?
 
In my understanding, out-of-body experiences are not necessary for the Work. They do help only as far as having a direct experience that we are more than our bodies, which can change some limiting beliefs or programs.

As far as Gurdjieff saying that people do not have souls until they create one, I think it all depends on how you define soul and what he meant in this particular case. Just because different people use the word 'soul' doesn't mean that they refer to the same thing.

One definition could be that 'soul' is a connection to higher aspects of Self or 'Source' that enables people to consciously work on their growth. And apparently, not everyone has this ability or connection.

The definition of 'soul' that Gurdjieff seems to be using is something akin to being a fully realized being - or reaching the highest potential in human evolution.
 
istvan_06 said:
Hello Friends,

I have two question:
1. What is the Fourth way saying about the Out of Body Experiences? A read a lot of success stories regarding to it. Those people all have got a soul? How can be so many self created soul? Or what is projecting out of the body?

As far as I know it says not much about it since in order to have Out of Body Experiences you have to have astral body first. People are probably born with just an embryo of astral body which if not developed during life disintegrates after the death of the material body.

Osha said Gurdjieff lying:
http://www.osho.com/read/osho/osho-on-topics/george-gurdjieff
"Gurdjieff said, “You are nothing but the body, and when the body dies you will die. Only once in a while does a person survive – one who has created soul in his life survives death – not all. A Buddha survives; a Jesus survives, but not you! You will simply die, not even a trace will be left.”

What was Gurdjieff trying to do? He was shocking you to the very roots; he was trying to take away all your consolations and foolish theories which go on helping you to postpone work upon yourself. Now, to tell people, “You don’t have any souls, you are just vegetables, just a cabbage or maybe a cauliflower” – a cauliflower is a cabbage with a college education – “but nothing more than that.” He was really a master par excellence. He was taking the very earth away from underneath your feet. He was giving you such a shock that you had to think over the whole situation: are you going to remain a cabbage? He was creating a situation around you in which you would have to seek and search for the soul, because who wants to die?

And the idea that the soul is immortal has helped people to console themselves that they are not going to die, that death is just an appearance, just a long sleep, a restful sleep, and you will be born again. Gurdjieff says, “All nonsense. This is all nonsense! Dead, you are dead forever – unless you have created the soul….”

Now see the difference: you have been told you are already a soul, and Gurdjieff changes it totally. He says, “You are not already a soul, but only an opportunity. You can use it, you can miss it.”

And I would like to tell you that Gurdjieff was just using a device. It is not true. Everybody is born with a soul. But what to do with people who have been using truths as consolations? A great master sometimes has to lie – and only a great master has the right to lie – just to pull you out of your sleep.

Osho, The Dhammapada: The Way of the Buddha, Vol. 2, Talk #2"

I'm not familiar with Osho but quick search on the forum reveals that he is probably another new agey "guru". Check this thread: http://cassiopaea.org/forum/index.php/topic,16796.15.html.

There is another solution. The OBE is an imagination and not truth. What do you think about it?
I tried OBE many times but never happend to me...

Why do you try it? Is it so important? Do you want to prove yourself that you DO have a soul?

2. If a man sleeps what happend to him? I read about that the links between centers are disconnected for a sleeping time. In what center are we then? Instinctive?
If the connections between centers are fully disconnected then you sleep without dreams. Sometimes the connections are just being weakened but not fully disconnected which makes you dream. All the centers continue their work independent from each other whether they are connected or not.


If I use self remembering why do not get myself full conscious during sleep?

Can you elaborate on what it means? Before you try any self-remembering exercises and get apparently good results which could be just your imagination, it's recommended by G. to try self-observation first. This exercise alone can take you several years. You have to know your machine (body) first.

And what will be a different when i will die? What will bring me conscious?

Have you read In Search of the Miraculous by Ouspensky? And perhaps other books from recommended books list (http://cassiopaea.org/forum/index.php/topic,33092.0.html)?
 
istvan_06, it would help you a lot to read The Wave series that you can read online for free. You can read it here:

http://cassiopaea.org/category/volumes/the-wave/

A lot of things are covered in that series. And a lot of what this forum is about is based on these books, and others, that Laura Knight-Jadczyk has written, since this is her forum.

It is mentioned how the Sufis think that Americans and Europeans are foolish to do these sorts of things (OBE and other spiritual pursuits) without the knowledge that is required to do them, as the astral planes are a jungle and very dangerous for those who do not know what they are dealing with.
 
Thank you for your reply. I do the self remembering exercise all day, it is a wonderful thing i did it for years before know what it is...
OBE/AP was just a tryout for me when i was teenager. I did not want to prove anything.

It is interesting that a lot of people can do it sooner or later. An another forum i found some man whose are writing/reading about it using mainstream esoteric words. Maybe they are using their "formatory apparatus", they are always on the bright side of life.

I will read the wave series i hope it helps. :)

Let me simplefy the 2. questions and ask it again. Where is "I" during sleep? "I" is that one who is in me watching when self remembering. I have read the In Search of the Miraculous by Ouspensky but find no answer for this question. OK, the body will die and the lower centers stopping because no air, no food etc. intake. If have an astral body man can live for more. Great. I asked a 4 wayer group a question: Does a Man Numbers 5,6,7 can be conscious during sleep? I can not get an answer.
 
istvan_06 said:
Let me simplefy the 2. questions and ask it again. Where is "I" during sleep? "I" is that one who is in me watching when self remembering.

I'm not sure I understand your question. The Observer is always there whether you notice it or not.

istvan_06 said:
If have an astral body man can live for more.

This seems to be an assumption.

istvan_06 said:
Does a Man Numbers 5,6,7 can be conscious during sleep? I can not get an answer.

I'm not sure that having lucid dreams and being conscious during sleep really matters that much.

It is true that usually there is a connection between self-remembering and 'waking up' in dreams too. In fact, to not lose the lucid dream you need to apply something very similar to self-remembering in the lucid dream.
 
istvan_06 said:
Thank you for your reply. I do the self remembering exercise all day, it is a wonderful thing i did it for years before know what it is...
OBE/AP was just a tryout for me when i was teenager. I did not want to prove anything.

It is interesting that a lot of people can do it sooner or later. An another forum i found some man whose are writing/reading about it using mainstream esoteric words. Maybe they are using their "formatory apparatus", they are always on the bright side of life.

I will read the wave series i hope it helps. :)

Let me simplefy the 2. questions and ask it again. Where is "I" during sleep? "I" is that one who is in me watching when self remembering. I have read the In Search of the Miraculous by Ouspensky but find no answer for this question. OK, the body will die and the lower centers stopping because no air, no food etc. intake. If have an astral body man can live for more. Great. I asked a 4 wayer group a question: Does a Man Numbers 5,6,7 can be conscious during sleep? I can not get an answer.

I still remember a dream I had over a year ago where I became lucid and began to fly. I soared as high up as I could, and saw that the dreamscape that I was in was more like a large dome; something with definite boundaries. At the top of this dome there was an opening, aid I could see a baseball field on the other side. As I soared towards it; spinning in circles while flying straight up; I lost my concentration and began to fall- very quickly. I closed my eyes and braced for a very painful jolt that would result from me hitting the ground; even in my dream state.

Instead of hitting the ground, I fell through it; into this void. The "void" was very similar to when you are playing a video game that has a glitch and your character falls in between the floors of the level, suspended in this black/ grayness while the world sits above you. I continued to fall for a second and then, literally felt myself fall back into my body through the top of my head. I felt my energy integrate into my being and it jolted me awake. This was before I even had an understanding of self-remembering in the sense that I do now.

From what I have gathered through personal experience, the "I" during sleep seems to be trapped in the same state as your "I" is while you are awake. Although I believe that some spontaneous OBE's are possible (I've had quite a few in the past, but not so much anymore), I think that the more one practices self-remembering and self-observing, the more things of that nature can become the norm- if that's what one puts their attention towards developing.

The thing with my dreams are that they are strange; but that strangeness if normal in the midst of a dream. Some videos and articles suggest giving yourself cues throughout your waking times to remind yourself to check whether or not you are still awake. Once this becomes a habit, some say that this may continue in the dream state.

I too share a deep sense of awe when confronted with the mystery that surrounds the out of body experience. I wish you the best of luck in your search!
 

Trending content

Back
Top Bottom