South Africa going the Zimbabwe route?

Erna

The Living Force
White farmers 'being wiped out'

South Africa: White farmers 'being wiped out'

Over 3,000 have been killed since 1994. Now the ANC is accused of fanning the hate.

White2385_702111a.jpg


A man walks through a field of crosses erected near Pretoria, South Africa,
to honour mostly white farmers who have died in farm attacks over past decade.



THE gunmen walked silently through the orchard. Skirting a row of burnt-out tyres, set ablaze months earlier to keep the budding fruit from freezing, they drew their old .38 revolvers.

Inside his farmhouse Pieter Cillier, 57, slept with his 14-year-old daughter Nikki at his side. His 12-year-old son JD was having a sleepover with two teenagers in an adjoining room.

As the intruders broke in, the farmer woke. He rushed to stop them, only to be shot twice in the chest.

In his death throes he would have seen his killers and then his children standing over him, screaming and crying.

The attackers, who were drug addicts, simply disappeared into the night. Cillier’s murder, at Christmas, was barely reported in the local press. It was, after all, everyday news.

Death has stalked South Africa’s white farmers for years. The number murdered since the end of apartheid in 1994 has passed 3,000.

In neighbouring Zimbabwe, a campaign of intimidation that began in 2000 has driven more than 4,000 commercial farmers off their land, but has left fewer than two dozen dead.

The vulnerability felt by South Africa’s 40,000 remaining white farmers intensified earlier this month when Julius Malema, head of the African National Congress’s (ANC’s) youth league, opened a public rally by singing Dubula Ibhunu, or Shoot the Boer, an apartheid-era anthem, that was banned by the high court last week.


Malema’s timing could hardly have been worse. Last weekend in the remote farming community of Colenso, in KwaZulu-Natal, Nigel Ralfe, 71, a dairy farmer, and his wife Lynette, 64, were gunned down as they milked their cows. He was critically injured; she died.

That same day a 46-year-old Afrikaner was shot through his bedroom window as he slept at his farm near Potchefstroom. A few days later a 61-year-old was stabbed to death in his bed at a farm in Limpopo.

The resurrection of Dubula Ibhunu, defended by senior ANC officials as little more then a sentimental old struggle song, has been greeted with alarm by Tom Stokes, of the opposition Democratic Alliance. He said the ANC’s continued association with the call to kill Boers could not be justified.

“Any argument by the ANC that this song is merely a preservation of struggle literature rings hollow in the face of farming families who have lost wives, mothers and grandmothers,” he added.

He was supported by Anton Alberts of the right-wing Freedom Front Plus party: “Malema’s comments are creating an atmosphere that is conducive to those who want to commit murder. He’s an accessory to the wiping out of farmers in South Africa.”

Rossouw Cillier, Pieter’s brother, bristled as he pointed to the bullet holes in the panelled kitchen of the farmhouse near Ceres in the Western Cape. “They shot him through the fridge from the back door — the bullets came straight through here, into his heart. He never had a chance,” he said.

A successful apple and pear grower, he believes his community is living on borrowed time: “More white farmers have been killed than British soldiers in Afghanistan and Iraq. Yes, we are at war here.”

His brother’s farmhouse is now shuttered and empty. “I can’t spend time here. We’ll have to sell. This farm has been in our family for generations but it must go. Who’ll manage it? The children will never come back here. They held their own father as he died in front of them. Will they ever get over that?”

As we walked across the orchard, fruit destined for the shelves of Tesco and Sainsbury’s in the UK was still being picked. A tractor passed a 10ft cross erected in honour of the murdered farmer.

“It lights up at night,” Rossouw said. “My brother was a religious man. It’s all that’s left of him here.”

Across South Africa many farmers feel endangered. In Northern Province a tribute has been created beneath an enormous sign with the stark Afrikaans word “plaasmoorde” — farm killings. Thousands of white wooden crosses have been planted across a mountainside, one for each fallen farmer.

Recently the government’s department of rural development has been airing proposals to nationalise productive farmland as a “national asset”. Critics claim it is designed to deflect criticism from the ruling ANC’s failures.

“It’s a lot easier talking about nationalising farms than building decent houses, making clean water come out of taps or honouring promises to redistribute farm plots to millions of landless poor,” said a spokesman for AgriSA, the farmers’ union.

On the outskirts of Ceres there are few groceries in the township store — tins of pilchards, baked beans, some dried biscuits. A group of teenage boys sit on the burnt-out remains of a Ford Escort. This is where Cillier’s killers gathered, in a shebeen, a drinking club, where they fortified themselves with cheap hooch before they set off to rob him. They escaped with nothing.

According to Rossouw Cillier the most telling detail is that his brother was unarmed when they attacked. “If we brandish a weapon, we’ll go to prison, not them. What did they gain from this murder? It was an act as pointless as their lives.”


Malema lauds Bob, says SA will copy Zim's land seizures

Malema lauds Bob, says SA will copy Zim's land seizures

ANC Youth League President Julius Malema yesterday endorsed Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe's economic policies - and threatened to import them to South Africa and to nationalise white-owned farms and mines.

juliusmalema1-200x0.jpg


In a fiery speech at a netball complex in Harare's Mbare township, Malema told a cheering 2000-strong crowd of Zanu-PF youths that, after his visit to Zimbabwe he was going to intensify his campaign for the confiscation of farms and mines in South Africa.

"In SA we are just starting. Here in Zimbabwe you are already very far. The land question has been addressed. We are very happy that today you can account for more than 300000 new farmers against the 4000 who used to dominate agriculture. We hear you are now going straight to the mines. That's what we are going to be doing in South Africa," Malema said amid cheers.

"We want the mines. They have been exploiting our minerals for a long time. Now it's our turn to also enjoy from these minerals. They are so bright, they are colourful, we refer to them as white people, maybe their colour came as a result of exploiting our minerals and perhaps if some of us can get opportunities in these minerals we can develop some nice colour like them."

Only five months ago, Malema said Mugabe should go - but yesterday he endorsed the Zimbabwean ruler, whose government has killed thousands of those opposed to Zanu-PF rule and overseen the destruction of the economy through land seizures.

Malema meets Mugabe tomorrow for talks before returning home. Today, he will visit farms and mines in a move calculated to fuel his campaign for nationalisation in South Africa.

Malema - who was introduced at the rally as a "young revolutionary icon" - said Mugabe was a hero in the mould of former Cuban leader Fidel Castro and his successor, brother Raul, because he was "not afraid of imperialists".

He also paid tribute to South African President Jacob Zuma, former president Nelson Mandela and Mandela's former wife Winnie - while lambasting Zimbabwean Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, whom he described as an ally of "imperialists".

The youth league leader's attack on Tsvangirai could compromise Zuma's mediation efforts in continuing talks between Mugabe and Tsvangirai on a unity government.

"We salute President Mugabe for standing firm against imperialists. The reason why they want him to go is because he has started attending to real issues," Malema said.

"To them he can stay in power for 100 years as long as he doesn't talk about the economy and addressing real issues."

In November, Malema said Mugabe must go. "He must step down - we need a new president in Zim," he said at the time.

"Zanu-PF is not the problem, the problem is the old man who is refusing to leave power," Malema said.

"And I don't know why the youth of that country are not taking him on."

However, yesterday Malema said that Mugabe was a hero.

He said Mugabe and Zuma, together with the ANC and Zanu-PF, had fought in the "trenches' together against colonial regimes and shared a common history with Swapo in Namibia, Frelimo in Mozambique and the MPLA in Angola.

He claimed western countries wanted to destroy Zanu-PF - and then deal with the ANC and other liberation movements to put surrogate parties in power, in order to retain control of resources.

Shifting attention to his homeland, Malema said SA was in desperate need of across-the-board transformation and fundamental reform, because the economy and even the judiciary and media were still "white-controlled".

He said "white males" were dominating those areas and were even banning the "singing of liberation struggle songs".

That, he said, showed democracy was too qualified in South Africa.

Malema said the ANC would not stop singing the "ayesab'amagwala, dubul' ibhunu" (Shoot the Boer) song, despite a court ruling against it and were prepared to go to jail for it.

"The judiciary is still controlled by white males who are refusing to change.

"The economy is still controlled by white males who are refusing to change and the media is also still controlled by white males who are refusing to change," Malema said.

"We can no longer sing liberation songs in South Africa because we will be arrested for undermining the courts. Now we have to go to Zimbabwe, Mozambique and other countries, like we did during exile days, to sing liberation struggle songs."

"We will never retreat. If it means singing this song leads straight into jail, we are prepared to go there. They can never tell which song we must sing!"

Yesterday morning Malema visited Zimbabwe's North Korean-built Heroes Acre, a burial ground for liberation struggle fighters, and a bombed house in Avondale suburb where ANC exiles lived.

He denounced political violence and claimed Zanu-PF would win free and fair elections if they were held in Zimbabwe.

He said Zimbabwe must defy sanctions like Cuba and "stand firm".

He then launched a withering attack on the media, saying they could write what they wanted, and that he did not care. He said Zanu-PF youths should not care about what the media said.

"You, the youths of Zanu-PF, must defend the gains of the revolution. You must be focused. You must be militant, radical and resolute," Malema said.

"We don't care about what the imperialist media write. They can write what they want.

"We are not products of the media, but of the struggle.

"So let them write what they want to write. We don't need a London newspaper to tell us who Mugabe is," said Malema.

"We don't need the so-called independent media to tell us who Zuma is. We know them."

Malema chanted Mugabe's and Zuma's names repeatedly during his rousing address, and closed by singing Dubul' ibhunu and Awuleth' umshini wami, to hysterical cheers.

Next, same as Zim, agricultural collapse and food crises... More than half Zimbabwe's population is in need of food aid today as a result of the white farm seizures.
 
E said:
Next, same as Zim, agricultural collapse and food crises... More than half Zimbabwe's population is in need of food aid today as a result of the white farm seizures.

Am thinking about the food aid: genetically modified wheat and dairy products. On top of Divide&Conquer, it's chemical warfare. If indeed SA goes the route of Zimbabwe the instability could spread further in the region.
 
This article is biased and it defeats the whole purpose of this forum. Although I am not at all into the politic thing, I am witnessing the unfolding of these events first hand in South Africa (which is my native country) and that is why I feel compelled to intervene in order to present a more or less balanced information for the benefit of the readers of this forum.

I believe that before posting articles like these ones into the forum, one must first try to be familiar with the geopolitical situation of South Africa (and the whole southern African region for that matter) in order to understand the way things are unfolding. As far as I understand the philosophy of this forum, members only need to know about WHY certain things are happening in this world rather than WHAT little detail is happening in every corner of the planet. I assume that most of the readers of this forum understand the fact that two divergent control forces which fight each others doesn't necessarily mean one is good and another is evil. And so in this case, members should not be fooled to believe that in South Africa, whites are the "good" ones who are being victimized by blacks - the "evil" ones. Besides, one might also keep in mind that most current killers of white farmers are former employees who are trying to settle the score with their bosses of Apartheid times.

I am not at all trying to deny the fact that some white farmers are getting killed in South Africa, but I simply like to give a more accurate context of the situation than the sensationalized version propagated by western medias which the poster of this thread intended to communicate. One must first investigate about the overall crime rate in the whole South Africa before assuming that ONLY white farmers are being targeted by criminals. It is estimated that about 42 people are getting killed each day in South Africa by crime alone (and that is just the official report), and most of the victims are poor blacks and who have nothing to do with the farming business. So to suggest that only white farmers are being singled out seems to me like a propaganda move which is intended to attract some racial sympathy. Because as far as our understanding here is concerned, EVERY life has an equal value and shoul be treated equally.

I would like to give the readers a few background information about the energy behind the events happening in South Africa. One should first realize the fact that socially and politically speaking, this country still has many unresolved issues which in one way or another will have to manifest themselves. As you may already know, the control system (which members of this forum are all too familiar with) has been showing its ugly face and its ruthless behaviors in this country for way too long! And unlike in many other places, its discrimination criteria was (and is still) mainly based on ethnicity and this means that a large section of South African population is still technically denied of any chance of future progress due to their racial heritage. I often get a disenchanted feeling to observe hordes of unemployed young people in South African cities who seem to have no future whatsoever, and who are now prone to substance abuse. All this can be attributed to the fact that the capitalist system and its economic status quo has cornered the wealth of this land and put a fence around it. It is a disgusting feeling to see how large sections of the country's land is still belonging to private individuals, and this capitalist madness has gone as far as to privatize all major national highways!! And what is even more frustrating in all this is the fact that it is the ethnic majority (meaning the native blacks) who are at the receiving end of this economic injustice.

What is happening here in South Africa (like what has happened in Zimbabwe and in all other African countries) is nothing but a revolt against the exploitation of the many by the few. That is why I beg the poster of this thread to explain to me exactly what he/she meant by "Zimbabwe route" because as far as I can remember, everything that happened in Zimbabwe has also happened thoughrout the rest of African continent a few decades ago. I also assume that most of the members of this forum are well informed about those who are currently manipulating the economy of this planet, and that is why it does not come as a surprise to me that Zimbabwe (and any other country opposed to the Anglo-American capitalist interest) had to be subjected to unreasonable sanctions which collapsed the economy of that vigorous country. Whether South Africa is next on the line does not concern anybody in this forum if I am not mistaken.

I do not wish to go into specific details about the current players of political scenes in South Africa (or Zimbabwe) and that is why I am simply limiting myself to the general observation of events. Yes, a few white farmers are also getting taken out due to this high crime rate we have here, but they are just victims among many more others. So fighting crime in South Africa cannot be dictated by the need of protecting white farmers ONLY but should be about how to prevent ALL killings in the country altogether, and this necessarily requires an equitable redistribution of natural resources to all the people of this land. Raising only the subject of white farmers killings (which represents a relatively small percentage of the total numbers of victims of crime by the way) is just demonstrating an old mentality of seeking special privileges due to a delusion of racial superiority. And frankly speaking, I am a bit disappointed with the administrators of this forum for allowing the posting of such kind of sensational topics which clearly propagate a racial agenda.
 
Hi Loire,

Not to take anything away from your analysis, but did you notice the date of the original post: April 05, 2010 -- well over two years ago ?
 
Hi Loire, this article was posted two and a half years ago, and note also that no one responded to it. What probably happened was that it was missed by the moderators and no other members chose to respond to it. The person that posted the article is very likely biased in favor of 'white south Africans', a term that is, as far as I am concerned, an oxymoron. I agree with your analysis and think it is an accurate reflection of the situation.
 
Thanks for reminding me about the date of the article. I did not pay much attention to it. Now I understand why it was ignored by others members. Because after all, nobody has time to waste in supporting an illusion of grandeur. Things do happen in this wrecked world of ours (good or bad). If the poster of this article feel like he can't handle the unfolding of events in this world, maybe he would do better to check out and stop wasting other people's time with meaningless information such as this article.
 
Loire said:
Thanks for reminding me about the date of the article. I did not pay much attention to it. Now I understand why it was ignored by others members. Because after all, nobody has time to waste in supporting an illusion of grandeur. Things do happen in this wrecked world of ours (good or bad). If the poster of this article feel like he can't handle the unfolding of events in this world, maybe he would do better to check out and stop wasting other people's time with meaningless information such as this article.


Very true. At least now that you have commented on it, it will be here as a reference and an indication of our stance on this particular topic.
 
Back
Top Bottom