Masamune
Jedi Council Member
According to this website there are many benefits of using the squatting posture compared to the sitting posture when evacuating the bowels.
Toilet-Related Ailments
Toilet-Related Ailments
We Ignore Squatting
At Our Peril...
The best posture for passing stools is squatting. In this position, waste elimination is easier, faster and complete.
Sitting, on the other hand, obstructs the passage of waste through the colon. Elimination is difficult, requires straining and can never be complete...
Many people today remain unaware that their sitting toilet pose a danger to their health and well-being.
In his book, A Guide to Better Bowel Care: A Complete Program for Tissue Cleansing Through Bowel Management, chiropractic physician and nutritionist Dr Bernard Jensen identified the sitting toilet as a health threat to mankind:
"It is my sincere belief that one of the bowel's greatest enemies in civilized society is the ergonomic nightmare known as the toilet or john."
To understand why squatting is better than sitting, one just need to have a basic understanding of how the colon works...from the point where food leaves the stomach...
colon, colon system From the stomach, food (all mixed and ready) goes into the small intestine where nutrients are absorbed. The food wastes then goes into the large intestine or colon. When it enters the colon, it is in a liquid state.
However, as it moves through the colon, water is continuously extracted, and it turns into solid waste (stools) by the time it reaches the rectum. It is then passed out through the anus.
It is crucial that the colon can perform its role efficiently and effectively. All waste must be evacuated on a regular basis to avoid the build up of toxins. For this to happen, one must adopt the squatting position.
1) Increased Abdominal Pressure
In the natural squatting position, the entire weight of the body rests on the feet, and the thighs are pressed against the abdomen.
This creates a beneficial pressure in the abdominal cavity, which compresses the colon, creates a natural urge to evacuate and helps force waste out of the body.
But there is more...
2) Protection of Appendix and Small Intestine
The colon - which comprises the cecum, ascending colon, transverse colon, descending colon, sigmoid colon, rectum and anus - is connected to the small intestine through the ileocecal valve.
The ileocecal valve acts as a one-way valve. It allows food wastes in the small intestine to enter the colon, but prevents fecal waste in the colon from leaking into the small intestine.
In the squatting position, the right thigh – pressing on the right side of the abdomen – squeezes the pouch-like cecum and force liquid waste upwards into the ascending colon and away from the appendix.
Hence, in the squatting position, the ileocecal valve is sealed securely, and both the appendix and small intestine are kept clean.
3) Release of Bend in Sigmoid Colon
sigmoid colon The colon also a kink or bend where the sigmoid colon joins to the rectum.
In the squatting position, the left thigh – pressing on the left side of the abdomen – supports and lifts up the sigmoid colon. This raising of the sigmoid colon opens up the kink to allow waste to flow easily into the rectum.
4) Straightening of Final Pathway
Just as there is an inlet valve (the ileocecal valve), there is also an outlet valve in the colon: the puborectalis muscle.
In the sitting position, the puborectalis muscle grips the rectum in a 'choked' position to maintain continence (prevent accidental release of stools from the anus).
In the squatting position, it relaxes its grip so that the pathway to the anus is straightened, to allow waste to pass out freely and easily.
sitting vs squatting
Truly, our colon is a marvel of nature!
The Case Against Sitting Toilets
By forcing users to sit instead of squat, the sitting toilet ignores ALL the natural requirements for effective waste evacuation:
1) Without pressure from the right and left thighs, no intra-abdominal pressure is created to facilitate expulsion of waste...
2) Without the action of the right thigh, there is no squeezing action to direct waste upwards and away from the appendix and small intestine...
3) Without the action of the left thigh, the natural bend between the sigmoid colon and rectum is not released...
4) The pathway between the rectum and anus is not straightened...
The outcome is obvious: difficult in passing stools. In frustration, one has to strain while holding the breath in order to 'push' downwards with the diaphragm (Valsalva Maneuver) in order to evacuate waste.
Yet, in spite of all the straining, the colon cannot be emptied completely.
Sadly, the impact of sitting toilets on young children is more serious.
When a tall adult uses a sitting toilet, his feet rest on the floor and his thighs are raised upwards at a slight angle and brought nearer to his abdomen and chest. He can also easily bend his chest forward to bring it closer to his thighs.
(Comment: This action to close the distance between the abdomen and thighs is not the same - or does not bring the benefits - as the full natural squatting position. But it is not as bad as the totally upright sitting position.)
But for young children who have shorter legs, the story is different. With their legs hanging over the toilet bowl and feet not touching the floor, they don't have any leverage to raise their thighs or bend their chest forward easily.
As a result, their colon is left totally unsupported.
It is worth noting that toddlers would instinctively squat, if sitting potties/toilets and well-meaning adults don't come into the picture.
Have Interesting Personal Experiences or Stories About Squatting? Share Them With Visitors!
What You Can Do... If You Want To Squat?
The best way, if you want to adopting the squatting position for your bowel movements, is to install a squat toilet. But check with your plumber if this can be done.
If installing a squatting toilet is not feasible, you could consider 'converting' your sitting toilet into a squatting type, by using a toilet squatting platform.
Book Recommendation
book about squatting, Nature Knows Best
If you like to know more about the benefits of squatting, I would recommend that you read Nature Knows Best, the first and only book on squatting in print today.
[Click here to find out more about Nature Knows Best...]
Twelve Most Commonly Asked Questions About Squatting
Like many who first came across information on this site, you may have many questions about squatting or what you can do about it. These questions -- and the answers -- can be summarised into twelve types/themes, as follows:
1. If squatting is so natural and important for health, why did the Western world and so many countries today abandon this practice?
2. Does it really matter whether I sit or squat? What is the big difference, if any, between the two toileting postures?
3. Will squatting cure my constipation?
4. Well, I don’t have any problems with elimination in the sitting position. Why must I bother about squatting?
5. Can't I get the same benefits of squatting with a sitting toilet by using a foot stool to raise up my legs and bring my knees closer to my body?
6. I want to squat but don't have any squatting toilet at home. What can I do?
7. Why do I need a toilet squatting platform? Can't I just squat on the toilet bowl?
8. Is a toilet squatting platform easier to use than a traditional squat toilet?
9. What are the pros and cons of a toilet squatting platform?
10. Can the elderly use a toilet squatting platform? How about small children?
11. On a toilet squatting platform, can I urinate as well?
12. What will happen to sitting toilets if everyone decides to switch to squatting?
1. If squatting is so natural and important for health, why have the Western world and many other nations abandoned this practice?
Although squatting is the most natural and effective posture for evacuation, a person can also use other positions when needed, eg: a sprained or broken leg.
For thousands of years, kings and queens, the rich and powerful have chosen to make use of this option to be 'different' and distinguish themselves from the 'commoners' or native people in the colonies.
However, it was actually in the mid 19th century that sitting toilets really took off. It was the beginning of the Industrial Revolution.
For the very first time, indoor plumbing became universally available. The early inventors and industrialists had decided - rather arbitrarily - to install seated water closets everywhere. They could have chosen to introduce squatting toilets, as these could also be used with the sewer piping system. But in a quirk of history, it was not to be…
Knowing nothing about physiology, the toilet inventors sincerely believed they were improving people's lives… The throne-like toilets would allow ordinary people to do it ‘differently’ from natives who squatted, and also make them feel like kings and queens.
Those who felt uncomfortable with this development were forced to keep silent. (In Victorian England, bodily functions were considered unmentionable.)
So from Great Britain, the most influential country in the world at the time, the fad quickly spread to the rest of Europe, North America, Australia and many developing countries. No country wanted to seem "backward" at a time when the world was making such rapid "progress".
Not long ago, the taboo surrounding this subject kept most of the Western world in the dark about how the human body was designed to function. Even today, not many are aware that the sitting toilet poses a serious threat to their health.
The continuing failure of the medical profession to educate people is especially regrettable. The situation has caused much needless pain and suffering.
[Back to Top]
2. Does it really matter whether I sit or squat? What is the big difference, if any, between the two toileting postures?
When a person squats, his or her thighs are pressed against the lower abdomen. The action of the thighs support and colon and causes the pressure inside the abdominal cavity to increase. The resulting natural pressurization of the colon facilitates waste evacuation.
In the squatting position, the pelvis is also suspended like a cradle, and the buttock opens up to expose the anus. Squatting also do what sitting cannot do: it "releases " the kink in the anal canal . This straightens the final pathway between the rectum and the anus, making it easy for waste to pass out easily and completely.
However, in the sitting position, the kink (bend) between the rectum and anal canal is not released. The abdomen (and colon) is also deprived of any support from the thighs.
As a result, a person using the seated posture for defecation is forced to hold the breath and strain and push downwards for waste evacuation. Yet evacuation can never be complete, resulting in accumulation and hardening of residual wastes in the lower regions of the colon.
All these things – opening of the buttocks, straightening of the anal canal, beneficial increase in pressure in the abdomen and hence compression of the colon – can only take place in the squatting position. The result is easier, faster and more complete bowel movements.
[Back to Top]
3. Will squatting cure my constipation?
The repeated use of the sitting toilet results in, or aggravates, many common conditions, such as constipation. Many people have found much improvement in their constipation condition the moment they change from sitting to squatting.
If no congenital factors are present and the colon has no physical defects, squatting – combined with adequate dietary fiber and drinking lots of water - will provide rapid relief from constipation.
It doesn't just apply to constipation. Squatting has also been found to improve haemorrhoid conditions within seven days. Children with bed-wetting problems have been known to attain normal control after a few weeks.
There is a decrease in the risk of bladder infections in women who squat to urinate. Also, women with bladder weakness and incontinence can regain normal control after about three months of squatting.
Men with uncomplicated lower urinary tract symptoms often improve after three months, and regain normal function after six months.
[Back to Top]
4. Well, I don't have any problems with elimination in the sitting position. Why must I bother about squatting?
Just as a person can get 'used' to tight fitting shoes etc, one can also get 'used' to sitting for defecation.
However, the price for persisting in this seemingly harmless habit can be high, when colon and pelvic-related health problems begin to manifest themselves ten, twenty or thirty years down the road. By then, it may be too late to do anything about it, eg: acute appendicitis, colon cancer.
[Back to Top]
5. Can't I get the same benefits of squatting with a sitting toilet by using a foot stool to raise up my legs and bring my knees closer to my body?
Having a squatting toilet is best. Using a stool to elevate the feet and bring the knees towards the body is not the same as squatting.
It is merely a crude attempt to imitate the natural squatting position where the entire weight of the upper body is on the feet, and the thighs are in contact with and pressed against the lower abdomen (see diagram).
The resulting increase in pressure of the abdominal cavity and beneficial compression of the colon results in comfortable and complete evacuation.
With a squatting stool, you still have to bend forward and use the awkward posture in an attempt to make contact with the thighs and compress the colon (see diagram).
This pseudo squatting posture is not the same as the natural squatting posture. You would still need to hold the breath and strain to push downwards to evacuate – which is not required when squatting correctly.
Straining in this way is the cause of hemorrhoids, diverticulosis and pelvic floor prolapse. Dr B. A. Sikirov, the Israeli physician who conducted successful clinical tests on the use of squatting to cure hemorrhoids (more on this study), found that the full benefits of squatting can only be achieved in the natural squatting position.
[Back to Top]
6. I want to squat but don’t have any squatting toilet at home. What can I do?
If you don't have a squatting toilet but you want to squat, you have, practically speaking, four options.
You can install a new squatting toilet. You can replace an existing sitting toilet with a squatting type. (These two options are often not feasible because of different plumbing requirements, building regulations or high cost.)
The third option is to construct a metal structure over your sitting toilet (see this real-life example).
The fourth – possibly the most practical option for most – is to use a toilet squatting platform (picture).
(Click here for more information about toilet squatting platform.)
[Back to Top]
7. Why do I need a toilet squatting platform? Can't I just squat on the toilet bowl?
Attempting to balance and squat on top of the toilet bowl is not only difficult, but dangerous and risky.
Most standard toilet bowls are not designed to allow squatting on the rim of the bowl, or to bear the weight of someone squatting on it (especially someone heavy). They have been known to give way and collapse, causing severe injury from pieces of jagged porcelain.
[Back to Top]
8. Is a toilet squatting platform easier to use than a traditional squat toilet?
A toilet squatting platform would be just as good as having a traditional squat toilet. It will allow you to adopt the natural squatting position, albeit at a height of 41 cm (16 inches) above the floor, over a sitting toilet (see diagram).
[Back to Top]
9. What are the pros and cons of a toilet squatting platform?
A toilet squatting platform will save you all the hassle and high cost of installing a squatting toilet.
The only "disadvantage" (if you want to call it), is that a user must be capable of squatting (for 5 minutes, or what you would need to evacuate). Also, s/he must not suffer from fainting spells or have a poor sense of balance, which can lead to falling off the platform.
[Back to Top]
10. Can the elderly use a toilet squatting platform? How about small children?
Squatting is for all – young or old. If you are able to squat without discomfort, regardless of your age, you can use a toilet squatting platform. However, if you have any feeling of unsteadiness or a tendency to lose your sense of balance, then you should not use it.
For those who are able to use a toilet squatting platform, it doesn't hurt either to take additional safety precautions. Either attach hand grips to the wall, or set a chair in front of the toilet (facing away) so you can hold onto the back of the chair.
If not for potties, young children would instinctively squat to answer the call of nature. Wrong toileting posture actually has a greater impact on children. Because of their shorter legs, their feet may not be able to touch the floor when they are on a sitting toilet.
Unlike an adult who can somewhat mitigate the effects of sitting by leaning their body forward towards their raised knees (and thighs) to mimic the squatting position, children can't. Their colon is left totally deprived of any support from the thighs.
For this reason, children should especially be encouraged and allowed to squat. However, they should use a toilet squatting platform with close adult supervision. It is best to let them hold on to a chair (or walker if space is tight) for additional support.
If you are really concerned about having your toddler squat but not above a sitting toilet, you can place two bricks at the sides of a bedpan-like container. They can step up onto the bricks and squat over the container.
[Back to Top]
11. On a toilet squatting platform, can I urinate as well?
Yes. Squatting is an excellent posture for urination. For men though, it may be necessary to aim downwards (hold and guide with hands if necessary). For women, it is even easier because their urethra naturally points downwards.
[Back to Top]
12. What will happen to sitting toilets if everyone decides to switch to squatting?
Not all should be consigned to the scrap yard. Perhaps a few could be salvaged for display in museums and schools, to serve as a reminder of the danger and folly of choosing form over function...
And as an example of a modern 'innovation' which have caused more harm than good. (A few other examples that come to mind: microwave ovens, leaded petrol, CFCs, aluminium and Teflon-coated cooking utensils, mercury dental fillings.)