Christian Archaeologists claim they have found Noah's Ark

  • Thread starter Thread starter tschai
  • Start date Start date
"I can't imagine what it could be if it is not the Ark," said Arch Bonnema of the Bible Archaeology Search and Exploration (B.A.S.E) Institute, a Christian archeology organization dedicated to looking for biblical artifacts...

....The Bible also describes the Ark's dimensions as being 300 cubits by 50 cubits -- about the size of a small aircraft carrier. The B.A.S.E. Institute's discovery is similar in size and scale."

Hmmm.....maybe it's AN ark. Personally I would expect THE ark to be much larger, assuming that it had to carry most of the species which are extant today. I'm joking of course, what is wrong with these people?
 
..."There's this idea, if we can prove that the ark existed then we can prove that the story existed, and more importantly, we can prove that God existed," said Bruce Feiler, author of "Where God Was Born."...

How could finding a boat prove that god existed? or that a bloke called noah built it? If there WAS a flood in the past then it's not beyond reasonable doubt that there could be remains of several boats from that period. Would it be likely that in the whole world only noah owned one?
The gopher wood is easy to explain imo. "I think I'll build missen a boat... go-fer some wood fer me will yer"?
 
Ben said:
"I can't imagine what it could be if it is not the Ark," said Arch Bonnema
<snip>
....The Bible also describes the Ark's dimensions as being 300 cubits by 50 cubits -- about the size of a small aircraft carrier. The B.A.S.E. Institute's discovery is similar in size and scale."
<snip>
what is wrong with these people?
LOL. lets get this straight. It MUST be the ark, because it measures 300x50 cubits?

right, I think its time to buy some timber and nails, crack out the carpentry tools, and 300 cubit ruler, and see if we can confuse them with ANOTHER genuine ark :D
 
sleepyvinny said:
LOL. lets get this straight. It MUST be the ark, because it measures 300x50 cubits?

right, I think its time to buy some timber and nails, crack out the carpentry tools, and 300 cubit ruler, and see if we can confuse them with ANOTHER genuine ark :D
You mean like this?

mycaricark.jpg
 
Hey Anart-That's because the measurements are equal to the Planck length... ;)
 
Currently I'm on vacation in California, and while walking on the street in Santa Monica I was asked by someone if I believed that Noah's ark was truly found in Mount Ararat. I told him I am very skeptical of it, but anything is possible. Of course, I didn't get in to the historical accuracy of any of the religious texts regarding Noah’s ark- as we know here, this story is probably fictitious like many other religious stories. But I thought I should bring it up here for discussion and since there is already a thread about it from 2006, I decided to resurrect this old thread. Here are the related articles.

_http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/worldnews/article-1269165/Noahs-Ark-remains-discovered-mountain-Turkey.html


'We've found Noah's Ark!'... claim evangelical explorers on mission to snow-capped Ararat (but British scientists say 'show us your evidence')

By Mail Foreign Service
Last updated at 2:50 PM on 28th April 2010


As believers in the literal truth of the Bible, they knew it was there.

Even so, the explorers who say they found seven large wooden compartments beneath snow and volcanic debris near the peak of Mount Ararat can be forgiven their excitement.

'It's not 100 per cent that it is Noah's Ark, but we think it is 99.9 per cent that this is it,' said Yeung Wing-cheung, a filmmaker working with the 15-strong team of fundamentalist Christians exploring the Turkish mountain.
article-1269165-09520B04000005DC-609_634x423.jpg

This picture released by the evangelical group claims to show one of the explorers examining part of a structure which they claim might prove the existence of Noah's Ark on Mount Ararat. There are no external images of the site and the Hong Kong-based group refuse to say precisely where they made their discovery until the Turkish government designate it an archaeological site
article-1269165-00431C9800000258-509_634x286.jpg

The snow-capped peak of Mt. Ararat. The discovery is said to have been made 12,000ft up the mountain which lies in eastern Turkey
They said wood taken from the site, which is more than 13,000ft above sea level, dates to 2,800BC. If it is the ark, the discovery would be the greatest in the history of archaeology and bear out one of the most famous stories in the Bible.

The team of Turks and Chinese researchers from Noah's Ark Ministries International in Hong Kong say they made the discovery on Ararat - the biblical resting place of the ark - in October
At a press conference yesterday to announce the discovery, another team member, Panda Lee, said: 'I saw a structure built with plank-like timber.

'Each plank was about eight inches wide. I could see tenons, proof of ancient construction predating the use of metal nails.

'We walked about 100 metres to another site. I could see broken wood fragments embedded in a glacier, and some 20 metres long.'

The structure had several compartments, some with wooden beams, the team said.

The wooden walls of one compartment were smooth and curved while the video shown by the explorers revealed doors, staircases and nails.

The team said the wood appeared to be cypress although, according to the Bible, the ark was built from gopher.

The group ruled out identifying the find as a human settlement, saying none had been found so high up in that area. They are keeping the exact location secret.

Four years ago and following a decade of research, U.S. national security analyst Porcher Taylor claimed a satellite image revealed a baffling 'anomaly' on the mountain's north-west corner that he believed to be the remains of the Ark.

But Mike Pitt, a British archaeologist, said the evangelical explorers had yet to produce compelling evidence.

He added: 'If there had been a flood capable of lifting a huge ship 4km up the side of a mountain 4,800 years ago, I think there would be substantial geological evidence for this flood around the world. And there isn't.'
article-1269165-09545C46000005DC-923_634x329.jpg


Nicholas Purcell, a lecturer in ancient history at Oxford University, said the claims were the 'usual nonsense'. He added: 'If floodwaters covered Eurasia 12,000ft deep in 2,800BC, how did the complex societies of Egypt and Mesopotamia, already many centuries old, keep right on regardless?'

According to Genesis, the first book in the Old Testament, Noah was told to build the ark by God, who wanted to flood the world to punish sinners.
The story was widely seen as fact until the 19th century, when scientists began to question the evidence for a worldwide flood.
article-1269165-09520A8B000005DC-75_634x399.jpg

This photo, also put out by the evangelical group, is said to show part of a wall inside the structure found by the explorers. One of the team said: 'It's not 100 per cent that it is Noah's Ark but we think it is 99.9 per cent that this is it'
article-1269165-0952D209000005DC-32_634x434.jpg

In 2006, U.S. national security analyst Porcher Taylor claimed this satellite image revealed a baffling 'anomaly' on the mountain's north-west corner that he believed to be the remains of the Ark
article-1269165-09520A63000005DC-772_634x356.jpg

Wooden beams which the explorers said they found at the site. The search for the physical remains of Noah's Ark has held a fascination for Christians, Jews and Muslims for hundreds of years. But despite various claims no scientific evidence has ever been found

Here is another article from a different source, covering the same story.

_http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/2010/04/29/2010-04-29_noahs_ark_discovery_claim_in_turkey_sparks_excitement_but_experts_remain_skeptic.html?ref=rss
 
Noah's Ark Found in Turkey?


Headlines -

The expedition team is "99.9 percent" sure. Others, well, aren't.


A team of evangelical Christian explorers claim they've found the remains of Noah's ark beneath snow and volcanic debris on Turkey's Mount Ararat.

But some archaeologists and historians are taking the latest claim that Noah's ark has been found about as seriously as they have past ones—which is to say not very.

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/04/100428-noahs-ark-found-in-turkey-science-religion-culture/

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This report will no doubt put a lot of US fundie Christians into a bit of a frenzy.
 
This mount Ararat has been researched for more than a thousand years, even by roman legions. And since it's on a mountain, a wooden contruction is unlikely to resist erosion for thousands of years, and thousands of curious believers.
 
Back
Top Bottom