Detroit Water Cut-off

Teresa

Jedi
Detroit is cutting off water to people who can't afford the high prices.

_http://www.iede.co.uk/news/2014_4783/water-cut-us-city-violates-human-rights-say-activists_

Water Cut-off in U.S. City Violates Human Rights, Say Activists
Thursday, June 19, 2014 - 04:20Inter Press Service


UNITED NATIONS, Jun 19 (IPS) - When the United Nations reaches out to resolve a water or sanitation crisis, it is largely across urban slums and remote villages in Asia, Africa or Latin America and the Caribbean.

But a severe water crisis in the financially bankrupt city of Detroit in the U.S. state of Michigan has prompted several non-governmental organisations and activists to appeal for U.N. intervention in one of the world's richest countries.

"This is unprecedented," said Maude Barlow, founder of the Blue Planet Project, a group that advocates water as a human right.

"I visited the city and worked with the Detroit People's Water Board several weeks ago and came away terribly upset,” she told IPS.

[pullquote]3[/pullquote]She pointed out that hundreds of thousands of people, mostly African Americans, are having their water ruthlessly turned off.

Families with children, the elderly and the sick, cannot bathe, flush their toilets or cook in their own homes, she added.

"This is the worst violation of the human right to water I have ever seen outside of the worst slums in the poorest countries in failed states of the global South," said Barlow, a one-time senior advisor on water to a former President of the U.N. General Assembly.

Last March, the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department (DWSD) announced plans to shut off water service for 1,500 to 3,000 customers every week if their water bills were not paid. And on Tuesday, the City Council approved an 8.7-percent water rate increase.

According to a DWSD document, more than 80,000 residential households – in a city of 680,000 people – are in arrears, with thousands of families without water, and thousands more expected to lose access at any moment.

A group of NGOs has submitted a report to Catarina de Albuquerque, the U.N. Special Rapporteur on the Human Right to Safe Drinking Water and Sanitation, urging the United Nations to weigh in on the crisis and help restore water services and stop further cut-offs.

In a joint report released Wednesday, the Detroit People's Water Board, the Blue Planet Project, the Michigan Welfare Rights Organisation and Food and Water Watch made several recommendations, including an appeal to the state of Michigan and the U.S. government to respect the human right to water and sanitation.

The report also calls on the city of Detroit to abandon its plans for further cut-offs and restore services to households that have suffered water cuts.

Mary Grant, researcher at Food & Water Watch, an advocacy group based in Washington DC, told IPS people often think the United States has fully met the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and provides universal access to safe drinking water and sanitation.

But as the crisis in Detroit shows, the situation is more complex and certain communities lack these essential services, she added.

When the U.N. Special Rapporteur on the Right to Water visited the United States last year, Food & Water Watch wrote a report delineating violations of the human right to water and sanitation across the country, primarily in rural, Latino and immigrant, Native American and homeless communities.

Grant said water shutoffs for non-payment are one way these violations are occurring.

In Detroit and other cities, she pointed out, households can lose access to drinking water and wastewater service when they cannot afford to pay their water bills.

The few low-income assistance programmes that exist are inadequate and fail to meet the needs of struggling households, she added.

"Water bills are regressive, so low-income households pay a disproportionate amount of their income for water service. Unfortunately, water rates across the country are increasing."

She said there are many factors driving this: federal assistance for water infrastructure has been cut back by more than three-quarters since the 1970s, ageing systems are reaching the end of their lifespan, and water quality standards are getting stronger "as we learn more about the health risks of substances that contaminate our water."

Large cities, in particular, are struggling to maintain and modernise water systems without making water service unaffordable for their least well-off residents, said Grant.

Food & Water Watch's research has found that communities experience even larger water rate increases when systems are privatised.

Grant said the shutoffs appear to be an attempt to make the water and sewer system more appealing to potential private investors.

Over the last decade, Detroit residents have seen water rates rise by 119 percent, according to a press release Wednesday.

With unemployment rates at a record high and the poverty rate at about 40 percent, Detroit water bills are unaffordable to a significant portion of the population.

Many of those affected by the shut-offs were given no warning.

"The infirm have been left without water and functioning toilets, children cannot bathe and parents cannot adequately prepare food for their families", the press release said.

Barlow told IPS Detroit is "the canary in the coal mine."

Through years of corruption and mismanagement, deep cuts to infrastructure and social security, the city is now bankrupt and unable to care for its people, she noted.

And years of neoliberal policies such as free trade, de-regulation and privatisation have allowed the wealth to be diverted to the suburbs and jobs to move overseas.

"Detroit is our collective future if we do not start re-investing in essential services, education and health care, local communities and sustainable local economic development," said Barlow.

She said, "What is happening with these cut-offs is a social crime.Here in North America we are creating failed states and punishing the most vulnerable among us with these ruthless polices of savage capitalism."

She said the city has experienced flight of wealth and business and as a result, the poorest and most vulnerable have had to pick up the tab for essential public services.

"Water rates have gone through the roof and people cannot pay. Let Detroit be our wake-up call. President Barack Obama must step in," Barlow pleaded.
 
Since early Spring, many residents in Ohio have faced the same problem. Mainly, inflated water prices by the suppliers. From what I can gather, the problem is multi-faucet.

On one end, gas and oil fracking operations extract from local aquafiers and streams, thousands of gallons a day/per well head with little or no accountability to amount taken. No meter - no charge - only thing required is an issued Permit on a certain location on the Zoning Map. Many Business enterprises fall under the same category, such as our Nuclear Power Plants.

On another end, in recent years, several Bill's have been introduced into the Legal System to privatize and commodify our public resources which are still pending. In the mean time, Corporations find "loopholes" in existing Law's to subvert and side step the process. The Residential Customer is placed in the middle - having to pay a high price for every "metered drop" of water.

The loopholes undermine President Obama’s Executive Order 13547, which is part of his Ocean Policy Initiative and the UN’s Law of the Sea treaty (L.O.S.T.)

Obama Admin Allowing China To Suck Water Out Of The Great Lakes
_ http://govtslaves.info/obama-admin-allowing-china-suck-water-great-lakes/#sthash.rk25KSE4.dpuf

Wednesday June 18, 2014 - Shocking statistics surfacing about record busting, low water levels in America’s Great Lakes make no mention of the sale of fresh water supplies by private companies to China, or of President Obama’s executive order and the legal loophole allowing these sales.

“Two of the Great Lakes have hit their lowest water levels EVER RECORDED,” the US Army Corps of Engineers reported early this year. Corps measurements taken in January of 2013 “show Lake Huron and Lake Michigan have reached their lowest ebb since record keeping began in 1918.” The chief watershed hydrology expert warns Americans that “We’re in an extreme situation.” Keith Kompoltowicz heads up the corps district office in Detroit as hand wringing, citizen angst, and shippers’ economic losses pile up.

“Plunging water levels are beyond anyone’s control,” says another expert, James Weakley. But in one of our most popular posts, last year we warned, “Lake Michigan water is being shipped by boat loads over to China! By using a little known loophole in the 2006 Great Lakes Compact, Obama minions are allowing Nestle Company to export precious fresh water out of Lake Michigan to the tune of an estimated $500,000 to $1.8 million per day profit.” Recent heavy rains and snowfall may mitigate low Lake Michigan water levels somewhat, but this trend must be stopped NOW.

President George W. Bush signed into law safeguards for maintaining Great Lakes water, but clever corporate profiteers enabled by Obama Regime bureaucrats discovered this unnoticed loophole. By terming Great Lakes water a COMMODITY, they are selling it off to companies like Nestle for very low prices. These water profiteers quickly realized a staggering “240 times markup, well over current production costs,” we reported. And so our American Great Lakes, which hold 20% of the world’s fresh water, is flowing into Asia.
 
angelburst29 said:
Obama Admin Allowing China To Suck Water Out Of The Great Lakes
_ http://govtslaves.info/obama-admin-allowing-china-suck-water-great-lakes/#sthash.rk25KSE4.dpuf

Wednesday June 18, 2014 - Shocking statistics surfacing about record busting, low water levels in America’s Great Lakes make no mention of the sale of fresh water supplies by private companies to China, or of President Obama’s executive order and the legal loophole allowing these sales.

Hi angelburst,

In following your post and the links provided, I found some inconsistencies with your source. I would be careful using anything from govtslaves.info. They are proponents of the "actor's theory" regarding the Boston Bombings. See here:

_http://govtslaves.info/oregon-emt-graduate-questions-boston-bombings-use-of-actors/

Also, they seem to support Alex Jones as well.

In regards to the Chinese using/buying the Great Lakes water, I am not sold on that as well. It is true that the lakes have been loosing lake level for some time now: http://www.wunderground.com/news/great-lakes-record-low-water-levels-20130206, but it is probably just from more natural causes (ie recent drought, climate/earth changes, possibly sink holes). This article seems like one of those "if humans are behind it, then we can do something about it" agenda pushers, instead of there being a more natural explanation, in which case we have no control.

This certainly does not mean I am ruling out any back door deals by the Obama Administration when it comes to American natural resources, I am just suggesting that this particular website appears to be cointelpro or at least useful idiots, IMO.

FWIW.
 
Back dated articles on China's exportation of water from the Great Lakes: the loophole being used - is that the filled containers are 5.7 gallons or less.

Great Lakes Law - A Blog on All Things Wet and Legal in the Great Lakes Region by Professor Noah Hall
_http://www.greatlakeslaw.org/blog/bottled_water/

September 10, 2013 - My new book, Modern Water Law: Private Property, Public Rights, and Environmental Protections, has been published by Foundation Press and is available on Amazon. I was honored to work with two superb co-authors on this book - Robert Adler, Interim Dean and James I. Farr Chair in Law, and Robin Kundis Craig, William H. Leary Professor of Law, both at the University of Utah S.J. Quinney College of Law.

Modern Water Law: Private Property, Public Rights, and Environmental Protection provides a comprehensive text to study the range of legal issues and doctrines that affect water resources in the United States.

The “bottled-water loophole” results from the Great Lakes Compact’s ban on diverting water out of the Great Lakes basin in containers that are greater than 5.7 gallons (such as a tanker) but leaving it to individual states to decide whether to ban diverting water out of the basin in smaller containers (such as bottles). Debate over the loophole has centered on whether the disparate treatment is required under international agreements, such as GATT and NAFTA, and whether giving states discretion over smaller containers could possibly result in depleting the lakes, one bottle at a time. (These debates have been discussed in previous Great Lakes Law posts.)

The debate, however, cannot be resolved without addressing another loophole in the compact, a loophole I call the “information loophole.” As described in my article, Capping the Bottle on Uncertainty: Closing the Information Loophole in the Great Lakes—St. Lawrence River Basin Water Resources Compact, 60 Case W. Res. L. Rev. 1211 (2010), this loophole results in part from the decision to treat larger containers (more than 5.7 gallons) differently than smaller containers (5.7 gallons or less). Specifically, users must report to their respective state any time they remove water from the basin in the larger containers, but individual states can decide whether to require reporting when water is taken out in smaller containers (if the user withdraws less than 100,000 gallons/day).

The problem is exacerbated by the fact that users are required to report estimates to their various states, and the estimates are often based on inaccurate coefficients that vary across jurisdictions, especially when trying to determine the amount of water that is used consumptively. Even the water use that is reported is only required to be publicly reported in the aggregate. These compact requirements are inadequate to address the concerns expressed by the Great Lakes Commission that accurate withdrawal data is “lacking for all water use categories for all jurisdictions” because “reporting consistency varies widely and withdrawal data is mostly estimated.”

Better information would help determine whether exporting water in smaller containers actually presents a threat to the Great Lakes basin. In addition, improved information would be useful for determining whether the disparate treatment complies with NAFTA and GATT, or if an exception applies. Currently, the lack of accurate information about water use within the basin weakens arguments on both sides and prevents resolution of the debate. Returning to the analogy of the Old West, it’s a little like showing up to a shootout at high noon with no bullets – both sides keep pointing at each other and pulling the trigger, but nothing much gets resolved.


We need to stop the exportation of water from the Great Lakes to China
_http://www.annarbor.com/news/opinion/we-need-to-stop-the-exportation-of-water-from-the-great-lakes-to-china/

Posted on Sun, Dec 19, 2010 - This letter is in regards to NAFTA (North America Free Trade Agreement). China is the biggest consumer of Nestle, which sells several brands of bottled water and the plant is based in northern Michigan. When John Engler was governor of Michigan in 2001, he made an agreement with bottle water giant Nestle, allowing them to open a plant in Mecosta County. They have then pumped more than a 1/2 million gallons of water a day drying up streams and ponds that feed the Great Lakes.

Note: The loophole is that China purchases bottled water from the Nestle Corporation which is shipped directly to China as a Commodity.
China has indeed been removing water from the Great lakes area through bottled water product agreements with certain global corporations for years and there has been nothing “secret” about it.
 
Thank you angelburst for the recent links. The loophole is without a doubt. And in a round-about way, we are selling Great Lake water to China via Nestle; however, I would like to make the point that no matter how much bottled water is sourced from the Great Lakes, it will never be able to compete with natural evaporation. 29 million gallons of water evaporate a day from Lake Superior alone, so as Lisa Borre, a lake conservationist, says in an article she wrote for Newswatch.nationalgeographic.com, "Even if each ship could carry 2.5 million gallons of water in bladder tanks, it would take more than 10,000 ships a day leaving Lake Superior to equal the amount of water lost to evaporation in one day."

_http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2013/08/20/where-did-the-water-go-busting-5-myths-about-water-levels-on-the-great-lakes/

I am not sure that it is possible for Man to compete with nature in this regard.

There are 6 quadrillion gallons of water within the Lakes, so I don't think they are going anywhere soon. In fact, we will probably have an ice age well before they recede too far.

_http://www.great-lakes.net/lakes/ref/lakefact.html

But again, just my 2 cents. I suppose the argument is really about ethics then. They sure built that loophole in the Bill out of pure greed because it's not like the folks that live around or by the Great Lakes are really seeing any benefit from the deals that are made. Case in point, the people if Detroit and northern Ohio who are having their water turned off while others sloppily spill Nestle water down their chin while eating their Tunafish on Rye at the office. Blah.
 
Arrangements have been made to help Detroit Water Customer's with an Aid Program (for those who qualify.)

Notice in the article, that in May, the Water Utility Co. sent out notices to non-paying customers and water service was shut off to about 4,500 households. The Water Co. then approached Detroit City Council for a 8.7-percent rate increase, while also instrumenting a 50-cent charge on "all" water bills - to be used to help qualifying low-income residents pay their bills. (In a sense, double dipping.) City Council approved the rate increase. While a select few will be helped through the aid agreement, there's an 8.7 increase across the board and another fifty cents per generated Bill of Service - adding to the Water utilities - bottom line profits. Same ploy used by Oil and Gas Corporations, for years.


Detroit water department to begin payment aid program after rate hikes, UN complaint
_http://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2014/06/detroit_water_department_to_be.html#incart_river_default

DETROIT, MI -- An $800,000 program to help low-income Detroiters pay their water bills will be put in place in July after services were cut off from some residents in recent months and complaints were made to a United Nations representative, officials said Tuesday.

With about 90,000 city residents and businesses behind on their water bills, the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department in March began more aggressively collecting debt.

In May, about 46,000 notices were delivered to non-paying customers and water was cut off to about 4,500 of them, said DWSD spokesman Gregory Eno.

With 24 hours of the shutoffs, 2,700 of them paid or made arrangements to make payments and had services restored, Eno said.

Last week, the Michigan Welfare Rights Organization, the Detroit People’s Water Board and the Canada-based Blue Planet Project sent a letter to Catarina de Albuquerque, special rapporteur on the right to safe drinking water and sanitation for the United Nations' Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

The letter expressed outrage over the water cutoffs and called the collection effort a "violation of the human right to water and sanitation in the City of Detroit."

“Many poor people are forced to accept payment plans that they know they can’t afford just to keep their water on (or lights, gas, telephone) until the next shut-off notice," the groups wrote.

Eno said $800,000 raised from private donations and from a 50-cent charge on water bills will be used to help qualifying low-income residents pay their bills.

"That's going to help out a lot of folks facing financial hardships," he said.

"If you meet those guidelines, they could get as much $1,500 to help pay their water bill."

Eno couldn't provide an estimate of how much is owed to the department in unpaid water bills, but said the debt contributed to the need for a 8.7-percent rate increase approved by Detroit City Council last week
 
angelburst29 said:
Arrangements have been made to help Detroit Water Customer's with an Aid Program (for those who qualify.)

Notice in the article, that in May, the Water Utility Co. sent out notices to non-paying customers and water service was shut off to about 4,500 households. The Water Co. then approached Detroit City Council for a 8.7-percent rate increase, while also instrumenting a 50-cent charge on "all" water bills - to be used to help qualifying low-income residents pay their bills. (In a sense, double dipping.) City Council approved the rate increase. While a select few will be helped through the aid agreement, there's an 8.7 increase across the board and another fifty cents per generated Bill of Service - adding to the Water utilities - bottom line profits. Same ploy used by Oil and Gas Corporations, for years.


Detroit water department to begin payment aid program after rate hikes, UN complaint
_http://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2014/06/detroit_water_department_to_be.html#incart_river_default

DETROIT, MI -- An $800,000 program to help low-income Detroiters pay their water bills will be put in place in July after services were cut off from some residents in recent months and complaints were made to a United Nations representative, officials said Tuesday.

With about 90,000 city residents and businesses behind on their water bills, the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department in March began more aggressively collecting debt.

In May, about 46,000 notices were delivered to non-paying customers and water was cut off to about 4,500 of them, said DWSD spokesman Gregory Eno.

With 24 hours of the shutoffs, 2,700 of them paid or made arrangements to make payments and had services restored, Eno said.

Last week, the Michigan Welfare Rights Organization, the Detroit People’s Water Board and the Canada-based Blue Planet Project sent a letter to Catarina de Albuquerque, special rapporteur on the right to safe drinking water and sanitation for the United Nations' Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

The letter expressed outrage over the water cutoffs and called the collection effort a "violation of the human right to water and sanitation in the City of Detroit."

“Many poor people are forced to accept payment plans that they know they can’t afford just to keep their water on (or lights, gas, telephone) until the next shut-off notice," the groups wrote.

Eno said $800,000 raised from private donations and from a 50-cent charge on water bills will be used to help qualifying low-income residents pay their bills.

"That's going to help out a lot of folks facing financial hardships," he said.

"If you meet those guidelines, they could get as much $1,500 to help pay their water bill."

Eno couldn't provide an estimate of how much is owed to the department in unpaid water bills, but said the debt contributed to the need for a 8.7-percent rate increase approved by Detroit City Council last week

I'm glad that people who need it are now getting some help. It does looke like Detroit's average water bill is $67 a month as opposed to the national average of $40 a month and for a family that is struggling financially, that's a bit steep.

_http://detroit.cbslocal.com/2014/06/23/nearly-half-of-detroit-water-customers-cant-pay-their-bill/

DETROIT (WWJ) – It’s a basic human right: water. But could the United Nations soon help the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department provide the service to struggling customers?

Water department spokeswoman Curtrise Garner says it’s a possibility — but for now, the water bills must be paid.

“We do have programs that do help those that are just totally in need; can’t afford it — but we also know that there are also people who can’t afford it would can not pay and we know this because, once we shut water off, the next day they are in paying the bill in full. So we do know that that has become a habit as well,” said Garner.

“At the DWAS Department — it’s not our goal to shut off water. We want people’s water on, just like they do; but you do have to pay for your water…That’s the bottom line.”

Garner said the reality is that nearly half of Detroit Water and Sewerage customers can’t pay their bills; and that has led activists to lobby the UN to step up and take action.

“If they do contact us we are willing to speak with them,” she said, adding “We owe it to the customers that are paying to collect from those that aren’t. Somebody has to pay for the water.”

And while Garner says water is “a God-given right,” she says there is a cost to move water from the water resource to the customer and that the infrastructure costs money.

According to the Free Press, the average Detroit water bill is now $65 a month — much higher than the nation’s average rate of about $40.
So, what’s the solution?

WWJ Newsradio 950 listeners have been sounding off on Facebook.

Posted Kathy Ward, “This is just insane. If someone is that destitute that they truly cannot afford their water bill, there are already welfare programs in place for that. I’m guessing those same people not paying their water also have a TV, cable, I-phone, etc. People need to get their priorities straight, not expect another government handout.”

Wrote Rodney Carter, “Call President Obama he has plenty of taxpayers cash to spend. Wasn’t that a campaign promise he made along with free rent and gas and payin’ my car note…Socialism only works if there is someone to pay for it.”

Calvin Adkins added, “If there are programs available to help these families, I am all for it. God has blessed me with ability to pay my bills so being hateful towards those who aren’t able is just not in me. Yes, there are able bodies out there abusing the system. And those individuals should be sought out. But before we go after those people, how about we go after the real welfare abusers. The elected officials, oil companies, insurance companies, banks, Wall Street. Because those abusers are the biggest beneficiaries of our hard work and tax dollars. Stop kicking those who are already down.”
 
Back
Top Bottom