An mundane explanation for the ubiquity of flood myths. (Just a guess of mine!)

Viktor

Jedi
I would like to share some thoughts of mine about why there is a ubiquity of flood myths. Perhaps I am utterly wrong. Anyways, let's go:

Maybe ancient civilizations' always having flood myths is not that odd, considering they all appeared on riversides, a place prone to problems with high-level waters.

Myths use to make things bigger. For instance, giants (a bigger human). So it seems natural to me that they would make myths about a really big flood.

Of note, while volcanos and earthquakes don't happen everywhere. Floods can happen at any place close to large bodies of water (sea or river).

Also at places away! As long as there is heavy rain. In a community on mountains, it might cause mudslides (it happens a lot at slums in Sao Paulo). Rains are also accompanied by a scary phenomenon: lightnings. That would further increase the fear of rain-caused floods.

I was also wondering: but why not many myths about droughts? What about when river levels are far below normal? I guess maybe because it's not something immediately destructive. Many might die due to it, of course. But it does not destroy buildings, and also it's effects are slower. It gives time to people go to somewhere else. Whereas floods quickly kill.

Thus, droughts would be far less traumatic. Even if even more deadly.
 
Pierre mentioned in his book that 90% of the Worlds cultures had a flood story (p114-115). This claim was based on a study done by Douglas Ettinger (2016), "The Great Deluge: Fact or Fiction?, Ettinger Journals.

That would tend to indicate that a great deluge or flood actually happened sometime in the past, as indeed it did..... in the middle of an iceage, the oceans rose approx 20 meters! Where did all that water come from? You're going to love his explanation! Check it out:

 
Re giants … The way you describe things you seem to dismiss the possibility that ‘giants’ roamed the earth. Yet, this is fairly well documented, mainly in skeletal finds, but ‘modern’ archaeology dismisses these as ‘artefacts’ and they disappear in some basement collection. Apparently the Smithsonian has quite a seizable number of them.

Now, if giants did really exist, by your logic, so would big floods?
 
Comets bring dust. Dust brings rain. Since comets are a recurrent phenomenon, so are the flood myths.

In recent decades, many cities in China have been affected by extreme precipitation events with the decrease of light precipitation. More than that, the extreme hourly precipitation and maximum hourly precipitation in summer over North China present an increasing trend, which indicates that the extreme precipitation events occurring in North China will increase.

(...)

Mineral dust is one of the main components of aerosols in the atmosphere, which is recognized as the most important source of ice-nucleating particles due to their high ice-nucleating efficiency.

 
Back
Top Bottom