anart
A Disturbance in the Force
Re: Counter-Gravity Mechanism
Another emotional response (and a rather silly one, really). It would be quite beneficial, ankhepiphan, for you to take a moment to examine the strong possibility that you ARE identified with this. That some part of you thought that by bringing this up you would get positive responses, encouraging your ideas - that you, in fact - expected it.
This is an implication that Data does not have an open mind - as was your comment about 'throwing the baby out with the bathwater' an implication that I was doing such a thing. Do you understand that these sorts of statements aren't only vaguely accusatory, but they are manipulative? Why would you feel driven to pepper your responses with such things?
Where is the emotional component coming from? No matter how much you repeat that you do not expect anything and that you are not identified with these ideas of yours - your words/actions indicate otherwise. Denying them really ensures nothing other than stagnation.
I realize this is rather tangential to the original discussion (
) - however - your responses are indicative of such a strong level of identification that I would be remiss to not bring it up. If you chose to not consider the validity of what has been written here, that is your decision, but, fwiw.
ankhepiphan said:I expect nothing from "anyone", and why should I.
Another emotional response (and a rather silly one, really). It would be quite beneficial, ankhepiphan, for you to take a moment to examine the strong possibility that you ARE identified with this. That some part of you thought that by bringing this up you would get positive responses, encouraging your ideas - that you, in fact - expected it.
s said:Simply sharing information to stimulate discussion perhaps with those who've done similar research, or others who have an open mind.
This is an implication that Data does not have an open mind - as was your comment about 'throwing the baby out with the bathwater' an implication that I was doing such a thing. Do you understand that these sorts of statements aren't only vaguely accusatory, but they are manipulative? Why would you feel driven to pepper your responses with such things?
Where is the emotional component coming from? No matter how much you repeat that you do not expect anything and that you are not identified with these ideas of yours - your words/actions indicate otherwise. Denying them really ensures nothing other than stagnation.
I realize this is rather tangential to the original discussion (
