Is Genshin Impact fine for kids?

If the video game is the main outlet or source of fun, it may be more harmful to forbid it. Maybe a better route would be to introduce a new, more constructive or creative activity that also hits the “relax and enjoy” circuits. Then offer the choice on a more regular basis and see what happens.
or, if you can afford it, and decide to get the game, participate in the activity with your girl... not as a way to monitor because she might feel invaded, but as a way to grow close to her and so that she feels like you appreciate her interest and also, so that she doesn't go through the experience alone and if you need to guide her at some point, you can.

Just a thought, because I think pinkfreud makes a good point, sometimes forbidden stuff is simply more tempting because it is forbidden and it has that air of taboo.
 
I watched the IGN review video and another one, and Genshin Impact seems like a harmless imitation of Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild. So my wife and I gave permission to our daughter to play it.

She downloaded it on her computer and couldn't get it to start. So I put my tech support hat on and got it working after some tinkering. Tech is not as easy as pushing install and playing it.

Hard to believe this game has made $2 billion.
 
When allowing a child to spend time in front of a computer, TV, tablet or phone, it is good to know the effects that such exposure will have on the child's brain and also later on the adult who will have to deal with these effects by trying to reverse them, which may not be entirely possible.

I would like to quote here an excerpt from the book: TECH. Criticism of the Development of the Technological Environment. Jan Białek, which I recently read:

translations from Polish

"Within 30 [of exposure to the screen] seconds, the brain switches mainly from beta waves, indicating an active, alert and conscious brain mode, to alpha waves, indicating the REM sleep phase, relaxation or awakening from sleep, a state of aimless fantasy and dreams below the threshold of consciousness.
Studies have shown that the left hemisphere of the brain, which processes information logically and analytically, shuts down... This allows the right hemisphere of the brain, which processes information emotionally and indiscriminately to act unrestricted. ...In people addicted to screen exposure, studies have shown atrophy, shrinkage or loss of tissue volume in the gray matter of the brain.
Areas affected by atrophy include the frontal lobe, which regulates executive functions such as planning, prioritizing, organizing, impulse control and performing actions. Loss was also seen in the striatum, which is involved in the reward system and suppression of socially unacceptable impulses.
Of particular importance was damage to an area known as the Insula, which is involved in the ability to develop empathy and compassion for others and the ability to take physical cues from emotions. in addition to the obvious link to aggressive behavior, these skills dictate the depth and quality of personal relationships.
Studies have also shown a loss of integrity of the brain's white matter. Heterogeneous white matter translates into a loss of communication in the brain including connections to and from different lobes of the same hemisphere, connections between the right and left hemispheres and pathways between the higher (cognitive) o lower (emotional, experiential) centers of the brain.
Reduced thickness of the cerebral cortex has been found among adolescent boys addicted to games and TV, and reduced thickness of the cortical layer in the frontal lobe has been found to correlate with impaired cognitive tasks.
Brain imaging studies have discovered decreased information processing and reduced impulse inhibition, increased susceptibility to reward and insensitivity to loss, and abnormal spontaneous brain activity associated with poor performance on tasks. Research on video games has shown that dopamine is released during gaming, with the hunger to play causing changes in the brain that are similar to drug cravings.... reduction in the number of dopamine receptors and transporters."



I watched the IGN review video and another one, and Genshin Impact seems like a harmless imitation of Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild. So my wife and I gave permission to our daughter to play it.

Harmless? I sense wishful thinking on your part.
 
Harmless? I sense wishful thinking on your part.
You may be correct. I am doing the best I can for my kids, and may very well be doing the wrong thing. I can see mistakes in the past that I wish I could change. In the current time, video games are a present feature of my household, and in my judgment it is not worth upsetting the balance in my household now to eliminate video games.
 
You may be correct. I am doing the best I can for my kids, and may very well be doing the wrong thing. I can see mistakes in the past that I wish I could change. In the current time, video games are a present feature of my household, and in my judgment it is not worth upsetting the balance in my household now to eliminate video games.
Yes, I see what you're saying, sometimes it's better to pick one's battles.

Not that Marek's concerns aren't valid, but I also think it's not the game alone per se, the gamer also matters in this instance. I believe that a person who may be prone to addictive behavior, due to whatever brain chemistry imbalance or emotional trauma, will find a soothing behavior one way or another, without the influence of screens.

So, I think at least half the equation, in making the decision, is how well you know your daughter and how present you are in her life hlat, and so if you do see a change in her personality after a while, then it may be time for adjusting, if not, the game could simply be mostly harmless.

It also matters, as you point out, how and why you're doing this. I have seen some parents giving screens to their children to simply shut them up, to not raise them essentially. But I don't get the sense that this is what's going on here.
 
My kids are good kids. They listen to my wife and me. They dutifully complete homeschool with my wife. They enjoy the extracurricular activities that they voluntarily choose, such as cooking class, clay sculpting, and baseball. They've never had cell phones and are fine with that. My youngest 2 has me sit in the bedroom at bedtime in the dark because they like it and we chat.

I'm reminded when I was a teenager playing video games Friday night, and my absentee mom happened to be around and demanded to know why I was playing video games instead of doing homework. Maybe because I'm the top student in my school and already do 3+ hours of homework Sunday through Thursday night, and if you were paying attention one bit or knew anything about me you would already know that?
 
You may be correct. I am doing the best I can for my kids, and may very well be doing the wrong thing. I can see mistakes in the past that I wish I could change. In the current time, video games are a present feature of my household, and in my judgment it is not worth upsetting the balance in my household now to eliminate video games.

I understand, I have an 11-year-old son myself and I try to keep TV and video games to a minimum, it is not easy because all his classmates free time is just spent in front of screens. They play online games together.
I try to organize his free time (3 times a week he has muay thai training, photography, swimming, and on weekends he is at my place )
He may not be prone to addictive behavior, nevertheless gaming will not be unaffected to a greater or lesser extent depending on the child.
 
To me, your approach sounds good hlat! Not that I have any experience with kids, but for what it's worth.. It's cool that your daughter asked you about playing that game - my folks had no idea whatever I was up to on the computer (well there were no parental control settings back then).. and I don't think they could understand whenever I'd talk about it... they didn't seem particularly interested OR disinterested... Nice work getting the game going for her too. Tech dad!

I do think screens are bad for us, maybe especially for very young people, but they're a huge part of our current reality..it's pretty unlikely anyone living in a modern civilisation is not going to grow up to be using TV, computers, eventually phones, a lot.. Sounds like your kids have a good and balanced relationship with them, and all those non-computing activities. IMO that balance is the most important thing.

When I was a kid my parents used to every now and then say "RIGHT. Today is a computer-free day!" and I HATED that...and often snuck in computer time anyway.. They definitely thought I spent too much time on the computer, though looking back I'd say I spent just as much time outside doing stuff. I think I had/have an addiction to *screens*, though have never been particularly addicted to playing games...they get pretty boring after a bit.. I spent increasingly more time using the computer as a creative tool, teaching myself to code & making art/music etc.. My parents eventually seemed to give up trying to limit computer time.

I think I definitely had a bit of an unhealthy relationship with computers.. It's only been as an adult in the last few years, after purposefully making myself use devices with screens less, particularly stopping at night, that I've come to appreciate the difference in feeling..

For me: Computer screens = tension, intense interest and focus, feeling like I'm sensing constant movement, but it's all mental - I forget I have a body so I end up sitting in terrible posture for way too long, moving nothing but my fingers. I have been known to sip a mouthful of tea, then forget to swallow it for an hour while deep into a project! I eventually find it hard to switch gears and pay attention to people around me...

When I turn off the computers = relaxed body, mental calmness, I notice my surroundings and feel like I'm part of them..everything feels slower and more normal...I can appreciate the quiet.. I can really see & pay proper attention to the people around me. I've come to cherish being able to go into that state, that state which I previously didn't even know I was missing...

Not sure what my point is exactly, but that I think it's probably good to not over-emphasise the videogames thing either way, so that your kids know it's just one part of their world and don't become obsessed with it.. Maybe they'll lose interest as they get older anyway, that seems like how it normally works for everyone I know who isn't a games programmer. Though I guess it will be different for current generations since games are much more pervasive now and with online multiplayer etc... I dunno....
 
My kids are good kids. They listen to my wife and me. They dutifully complete homeschool with my wife. They enjoy the extracurricular activities that they voluntarily choose, such as cooking class, clay sculpting, and baseball. They've never had cell phones and are fine with that. My youngest 2 has me sit in the bedroom at bedtime in the dark because they like it and we chat.

I'm reminded when I was a teenager playing video games Friday night, and my absentee mom happened to be around and demanded to know why I was playing video games instead of doing homework. Maybe because I'm the top student in my school and already do 3+ hours of homework Sunday through Thursday night, and if you were paying attention one bit or knew anything about me you would already know that?
That's very endearing hlat,

And it seems like you're also processing some of your own stuff as your kid's parent, turning your experience into choices. And depending on how it goes, maybe one day you can write an objective review of the game in this thread, so that others who may be in similar situations can benefit from your experience also.
 
Anyone have any particular objections to the game Honkai Star Rail? It is made by the same company that makes Genshin Impact. My daughter has asked for my permission to play the game. I'm fine with Genshin Impact and haven't found anything particularly objectionable about Honkai Star Rail so far.
 
Back
Top Bottom