Lectins - a defense mechanism of plants

I was thinking about the "Invalid Inferences" talk in relation to Sayer Ji's lectin articles. We do need more verifiable information, and we need to verify it. My impression is that some of the articles posted on GreenMedInfo and written by other authors are questionable. All can say at this point is be careful, and question everything you read, especially when it comes from a single source.
 
Gertrudes said:
Mat: When I have looked at the totality of the evidence, and when it comes to grains
and legumes, I am pretty sure that it is the proteins that are problematic.

Well, lectin is a protein (_http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lectin). Some are considered to be resistant to proteolytic digestion in the stomach and to be heat stable as well.

Cordain does consider the role of lectins in food even after processing and heating. Biologists themselves might not be well acquainted with studies done in terms of the role of lectins in human disease. The argument is that dry heat might not be enough to neutralize lectins.

For instance:

http://www.krispin.com/lectin.html

There has been some information that lectins may be inactivated by soaking, sprouting, cooking or fermenting. Soaking legumes over night, draining the water, rinsing and draining again does seem to remove or inactivate many of the lectins. Heating seems to remove others in some foods but not all. There is little data to prove that any of these methods remove lectins completely as few foods have been tested and of those that have lectins many seem to remain after processing.

Excerpt from Plant Lectins , Pusztai A, Cambridge University Press 1991 pg.108

Nachbar and Oppenheim (1980) found 30% of fresh and PROCESSED foods contained active lectins. Lectins from green salads, fruits, spices, seeds, dry cereals and nuts (even after roasting) showed activity of potentially toxic lectins. Some of these lectins interact with serum or salivary components and bacteria from the oral cavity (Gibbons & Dankers, 1981).

Another example of the hardiness of lectins is the study by Klurfeld DM and Kritchevsky D Lipids 1987 Sep:22(9):667-8,

Isolation and quantitation of lectins from vegetable oils.

Results-Unrefined soy oils contained 858-2983 mcg/kg. After refining oils contained 24-55 mcg/kg. Both refined and unrefined soy oil contained soy lectins.

From Plant Lectins A Pusztai 1991 Table 6.9 page 179

Common features of toxic (non-nutritive) effects in lectin-gut interactions.
High degree of resistance to gut proteolysis.Binding to brush border cells; damage to microvillus membrane; shedding of cells; reduction in the absorptive capacity of the small intestine.Increased endocytosis; induction of hyperplastic growth of the small intestine; increased turnover of epithelial cells.Interference with the immune system; hypersensitivity reactions. Interference with the microbial ecology of the gut; selective overgrowth.Direct and indirect effects (hormones, etc.) on systemic metabolism.

Especially note #5. The popular Candida Diet is essentially a high protein, low carbohydrate diet which limits starches and sugars and thereby limits lectins. If lectins are a problem for this person (the so-called 'candida' patient) lectin ingestion may be associated with overgrowth of various gut pathogens that may include yeasts and removal of lectins would restore the gut ecology and the gut immune system. If this is true, the diet does not get rid of yeast but relieves the person from symptoms and pathogenic consequences caused by ingestion of lectins to which he or she is intolerant..

Lectins are hardy proteins that do not break down easily. They are resistant to stomach acid and digestive enzymes.

Other examples:

Modulation of immune function by dietary lectins in rheumatoid arthritis
http://www.direct-ms.org/pdf/MolecularMimicryOther/Arthritis.pdf

Agrarian diet and diseases of affluence – Do evolutionary novel dietary lectins cause leptin resistance?
http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6823/5/10

Dietary Lectins as Disease Causing Toxicants
http://www.pjbs.org/pjnonline/fin1120.pdf

Immunoblotting detection of lectins in gluten and white rice flour
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/entrez/3827897?dopt=Abstract&holding=f1000,f1000m,isrctn

Megan said:
I was thinking about the "Invalid Inferences" talk in relation to Sayer Ji's lectin articles. We do need more verifiable information, and we need to verify it. My impression is that some of the articles posted on GreenMedInfo and written by other authors are questionable. All can say at this point is be careful, and question everything you read, especially when it comes from a single source.

The article in question was written by Sayer Ji but I noticed that other authors started contributing and now there is a disclaimer that articles might not represent the views of greenmedinfo.com. I've corresponded with Sayer Ji before and I know that he is very open minded, inviting people to find holes and inconsistencies on his thesis and articles so he can improve them.
 

How to Reduce Lectins in Your Diet​

Story at a glance:
  • Many lectins are proinflammatory, immunotoxic, neurotoxic and cytotoxic. Certain lectins may also increase blood viscosity, interfere with gene expression and disrupt endocrine function
  • Among the most problematic lectin-containing foods are corn, corn-fed meats, casein A1 milk, peanuts, cashews and unfermented soybeans. These are best avoided altogether
  • High-lectin foods such as legumes and grains can be made safe to eat by proper soaking and cooking. Sprouting, fermenting and removing skins and seeds will also help reduce lectins in your diet
 

Attachments

Trending content

Back
Top Bottom