Thanks as always for the thought provoking session.
The music question is imo indeed a can o f worms. As a musician, recording and mixing engineer I have a few questions. Electronic music as defined by what exactly? By electronic music do they mean all the parts of the song are made by synths?
Let’s take pink Floyd for example, majority of their songs are drums, bass, guitar and vocals, ( non electronic) with some electronic elements as well, how does that balance out? Or does any electronic element make it “anti human”?
The majority of the music I make is sampled (real) drums, guitar, my voice, bass, sampled orchestral strings etc with some fully electronic elements, so I am interested in how that works?
Also, when we record anything, we transform it from an analogue wave into digital, then we mix and master and export it to an mp3 or wav file to be listened to on Spotify or cd or what ever. So does that process make it anti human too? Digitising it? What about reverb and delay and all the other things we use to enhance the sound? Eq is something that is in everything and it changes the frequency by enhancing or reducing parts of the frequencies in the instrument so it fits together with all the other instruments.
If/when we're doing things correctly, the videos are helping to spur thought, reflection and questioning - less any emotional engagement (though I can see how they can skirt the border of informational/emotional in a few instances). So, like any tool, we just keep firmly in mind that it is the intent behind their (proper) use, and making important distinctions between what's informative and what it isn't, that matters greatly, and counts for so much.
So we keep doing what we are doing?