Snowpiercer(2013)

edgitarra

Jedi Council Member
I saw this movie last week, it's a long time since I didn't see such a mind-blowing movie. It is a movie which is full of symbols, with great plot twists, an original scenario and great actors. The director of this movie which is also the writer of it(along with someone else) simply managed to put the hierarchical structure of the world into the size of a long train. I could never imagine that could be done, it stroke me unexpectedly. The story described on IMDB is this:

In a future where a failed global-warming experiment kills off most life on the planet, a class system evolves aboard the Snowpiercer, a train that travels around the globe via a perpetual-motion engine.
Apparently this experiment led to a complete freeze of the planet, and the only survivors live in that train.

Here's the link for the movie:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1706620/

And the trailer:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i3JwD5OZI9M
 
Looks good, but this is a South Korean film and the US release is in June 2014. It is mostly in English though. Did you see the Korean release?
 
I am going to be honest and say that the movie can be found on various online streaming websites. It is mainly in english and it is already in High Definition. This is how I watched it. There is a network called Yify, and they are nowadays on of the most visited website in world, as they also stream movies online.

I know it is not fair to do it, movies are expensive for my budget(not really an excuse, just a factor), so I watch it like this. Hopefully, I will get over it.
 
I saw this movie last week, it's a long time since I didn't see such a mind-blowing movie. It is a movie which is full of symbols, with great plot twists, an original scenario and great actors. The director of this movie which is also the writer of it(along with someone else) simply managed to put the hierarchical structure of the world into the size of a long train. I could never imagine that could be done, it stroke me unexpectedly. The story described on IMDB is this:

Spoiler:

I also watched it when it came, it is as said symbolic, in the end there was no need for train because life was possible outside it even if they said it was not and there was no alternative and showed the kids frozen corpses of some people that tried to escape when the train was crossing through that position. It depicts very well the madness of society and it s programming and manipulations, human actions in times of desperation and what are they ready to do about it and to other people. In the end train wrecked but as I see it, it is only a matter of time like in real life, and the new reality was revealed in the end, and previous as lie and scam for power games. It is also a programming for what is to come.

I am going to be honest and say that the movie can be found on various online streaming websites. It is mainly in english and it is already in High Definition. This is how I watched it. There is a network called Yify, and they are nowadays on of the most visited website in world, as they also stream movies online.

I know it is not fair to do it, movies are expensive for my budget(not really an excuse, just a factor), so I watch it like this. Hopefully, I will get over it.

I also watched it online but there are sites where it can be downloaded, but I do not see why it is not fair, those corporations or their owners if you like it better earn millions or even billions of dollars from taxpayer money, poisons they sell to you and propagating lies, and from robbing of other countries and enslaving you to work from them all life for leftovers. So is it not fair? Long way from it and you are the one that is being treated unfairly. Of course I am not going to pay for it.
 
Corvinus said:
I also watched it online but there are sites where it can be downloaded, but I do not see why it is not fair, those corporations or their owners if you like it better earn millions or even billions of dollars from taxpayer money, poisons they sell to you and propagating lies, and from robbing of other countries and enslaving you to work from them all life for leftovers. So is it not fair? Long way from it and you are the one that is being treated unfairly. Of course I am not going to pay for it.

I don't think it is about the corporations here. I think it is not fair to the team who invested time in making the movies, who agree to sell it. This is why it is called "stealing". This is not about corporations earning millions or stealing or lying. It is about my actions, and choosing(even though i still "steal") not to be like them. Otherwise, let's just go and rob their banks and shoot people just because corporations are doing what they are doing.
 
edgitarra said:
I saw this movie last week, it's a long time since I didn't see such a mind-blowing movie. It is a movie which is full of symbols, with great plot twists, an original scenario and great actors. The director of this movie which is also the writer of it(along with someone else) simply managed to put the hierarchical structure of the world into the size of a long train. I could never imagine that could be done, it stroke me unexpectedly.

Just watched and wouldn't recommend it. I thought it was utterly absurd and unnecessarily gratuitously violent. Granted there are some metaphors about society but I didn't find it a particularly enjoyable 'journey'. It starts off as a kind of low budget British gritty drama and then evolves into a dark, twisted Al-Gore-sponsored South Korean blood-fest. - Maybe I've been watching too much Downton Abbey :huh:
 
I don't think it is about the corporations here. I think it is not fair to the team who invested time in making the movies, who agree to sell it. This is why it is called "stealing". This is not about corporations earning millions or stealing or lying

Of course it is about corporations, they own movie companies and get most profits from it, and they are greedy and that is why they want to take down many sites like mentioned to get more money even when having enough already.

It is about my actions, and choosing(even though i still "steal") not to be like them. Otherwise, let's just go and rob their banks and shoot people just because corporations are doing what they are doing.

So in other words you are letting them use you in a big way? They use you through the system and you are ready to play by the book still and pay them for trivial things like movies. I think they are very pleased to hear that. I would not call stealing from those who steal theft, more like a balancing action, at least that is how I see it. And you are not like them, they have all and anything they want and you do not have money for some basic things, it is not so black and white even if it sounds funny from a blacker perspective saying I am not like them because they steal even though I still steal. I had a good laugh on it, I have to admit. That above quote reminds me of that extreme protestant capitalist work logic, if you have not it is because you are lazy no-gooder, and you should accept that situation because you deserve it. It seems you have difficulties with that like me when it comes to paying for trivials like movies and broader I assume.

Banks are a far away from movies, and shooting people can be avoided if willing, and money can be also given to those that have not and are starving or worse if one is compassionate and has conscience (Problem with banks is that even if professional you get cought if repeating it to many times, many do because they gamble all the money and they got used living doing nothing so they do it again. Smart people do it once and do big cash and disappear, so there is no use in that action.). Even if different from movies let s take your way and an example of starving man who stole one apple from fruit company that got him in the first place to starvation by declining his fruit buisness, so in that situation you would choose to not be like that corporation? Have you ever been hungry in life from not having? Have you ever seen real people dying from starvation?

It is easy to play some higher morality when in a comfy chair and with full belly, real situation and empty belly are althogether different realities.

I thought it was utterly absurd and unnecessarily gratuitously violent. Granted there are some metaphors about society but I didn't find it a particularly enjoyable 'journey'.

We do not live in "enjoyable" planet and I would not also like you call slave rebellion enyojable journey, that is if you did not expect sunshines and rainbows.
 
Tell me please, corvinus, do you think you are not being used? Because I think you are very wrong in this way. Of course I am used, we all live in this society and we are used in one way or another. Even if you pay taxes you are used. If I would stop "stealing" movies, I would stop watching them, not paying for them. I never paid for movies. Please tell me about you trying not to be used. We are used every single possible way. Can you stop the NSA watching you. NO! Can you stop paying markets for providing you with food? NO! It is not pleasant of course, but you have no other choice to realize where you are, and what your position is. I am slave in this society, just like you. Don't try to separate yourself when writing comments like this. Check other threads on the forum if you want to find why isn't it fair to watch movies in this way(stealing), or downloading books in pirate pdf's. Maybe I am not good enough at explaining.


And if you think that "stealing" and not buying movies means that you don't let yourself being used by them, that is foolish. They can know if you steal them and they can make your life miserable. But maybe you would enjoy taking a big fine, just because you don't want to let them use you.

Again, I would recommend you to check all your cognitive fallacies, you prejudge to much with your "tough" comments, because in the way you try to read "me" you pretty much fail at doing it. Maybe practice more at that.
 
Corvinus said:
Have you ever been hungry in life from not having? Have you ever seen real people dying from starvation?

Yes, I have been! You have a big lack of external consideration Corvinus. My family could barely manage to sustain itself, living in Romania was hard as hell. At one point we didn't have anything else to eat but bread and jam. My life wasn't easy at all.
And yes I saw real people, that didn't have nothing to eat, staying in outside in the winter.

Maybe this is an insight for you:
Q: (L) What is the meaning of the number 666 in the book of
Revelation?
A: Visa.
Q: (L) You mean as in credit card?
A: Yes.
Q: (L) Are credit cards the work of what 666 represents?
A: Yes?
Q: (L) Should we get rid of all credit cards?
A: Up to you.
Q: (L) Would it be more to our advantage than not to disconnect ourselves from the credit system?
A: Isn't just credit also debit.
Q: (L) Is that an affirmative.
A: How are you going to do this?
Q: (L) Well, do you have any suggestions?
A: World will soon have nothing but credit and debit have you not heard of this new visa debit cards this is the future of money as controlled by the world banking system i.e. the brotherhood i.e. Lizards i.e. antichrist.
Q: (L) If I don't have a credit card then I don't have to belong to this system?
A: No. You will have no choices: belong or starve.
Q: (L) What happened to free will?
A: Brotherhood AKA Lizards AKA antichrist has interfered with free will for 309000 years. They are getting desperate as we near the change.
Q: (V) It has always been my nature to rebel against that which I did not feel was good for me. Is rebellion against this system possible?
A: If you are willing to leave the body.
Q: (L) Leave the body as in death, croak, kick the bucket?
A: Yes.
Q: (L) If we were to move...
A: Changes will follow turmoil be patient.
 
Corvinus said:
...That above quote reminds me of that extreme protestant capitalist work logic, if you have not it is because you are lazy no-gooder, and you should accept that situation because you deserve it...
That leads to a problem that is not see the poor. So the poor, who has no job or has a precarious job, without access to health system and education, is a "LOSER". And that way is left with only feel blame himself for not taking advantage of opportunities. Opportunities they never had, most of the cases.
Protestant work culture also has some very good things, as Laura said about her education.
Corvinus said:
Banks are a far away from movies, and shooting people can be avoided if willing, and money can be also given to those that have not and are starving or worse if one is compassionate and has conscience (Problem with banks is that even if professional you get cought if repeating it to many times, many do because they gamble all the money and they got used living doing nothing so they do it again. Smart people do it once and do big cash and disappear, so there is no use in that action.). Even if different from movies let s take your way and an example of starving man who stole one apple from fruit company that got him in the first place to starvation by declining his fruit buisness, so in that situation you would choose to not be like that corporation? Have you ever been hungry in life from not having? Have you ever seen real people dying from starvation?

It is easy to play some higher morality when in a comfy chair and with full belly, real situation and empty belly are althogether different realities.

I thought it was utterly absurd and unnecessarily gratuitously violent. Granted there are some metaphors about society but I didn't find it a particularly enjoyable 'journey'.

We do not live in "enjoyable" planet and I would not also like you call slave rebellion enyojable journey, that is if you did not expect sunshines and rainbows.
I agree with what you say, Corvinus. I know you talk about something very real and hard, but you may have been aggressive with that "Have you ever been hungry from not having in life? Have you ever seen real people dying from starvation?" and what followed this. So, that is why edgitarra felt attacked, I think.

edgitarra said:
Check other threads on the forum if you want to find why isn't it fair to watch movies in this way(stealing), or downloading books in pirate pdf's. Maybe I am not good enough at explaining.
It is a complex issue which I would like to learn more. On download books or movies, I agree that we have to pay for the work done by others, but for some people there is not alternative (not my case). There are people with few resources but they have internet access (in a bar or wherever). For them, download books and movies is often the only way they could learn and experience intellectual new things. And I think we have to defend that. Maybe there exist the good thief?.
 
Hi edgitarra I understand your reasons that you are against downloading or watching movies online, what I don't understand is that at the same time you advertise a certain network and that they're ''the most visited website in the world and also stream movies online''. Why would you do that?

I also understand your reasons Corvinus to a certain extent, but as you know we don't support/condone activity such as downloading movies or books (which is illegal in some countries). Edgitarra makes a good point that you could be shooting yourself in the foot here, and that people who put effort in for example writing a book need to make their living also. There may be exceptions, when a certain book is highly priced, but even in such a case, one can give back by sending a donation to the author, writing a review, or both.

Also, Corvinus, you've been rude in some of your comments (just because someone doesn't have the same opinion on a certain movie as yours, that doesn't make it so that they're 'wrong'). Also, your comments towards edgitarra could've been worded differently. And edgitarra you seem to be biting back with your comment here: ''because in the way you try to read "me" you pretty much fail at doing it. Maybe practice more at that.'' Please try to be more civil with each other.
 
Protestant work culture also has some very good things, as Laura said about her education.

I agree, they have good work ethic but is based on above mentioned - fear of being unworthy or even condemed, it is mechanical not conscious, but there are always exceptions that do the work for sake of work. No wonder that capitalism originated and had fertile ground there.

I also understand your reasons Corvinus to a certain extent, but as you know we don't support/condone activity such as downloading movies or books (which is illegal in some countries). Edgitarra makes a good point that you could be shooting yourself in the foot here, and that people who put effort in for example writing a book need to make their living also. There may be exceptions, when a certain book is highly priced, but even in such a case, one can give back by sending a donation to the author, writing a review, or both.

I know that, that is why I said movies, I know some authors are surviving on their work when it comes to books and that they do not have much, to them I would pay even if not having it at the moment and paying at latter times when having. Hollywood is different thing althogether when broader picture is assesed.

Also, Corvinus, you've been rude in some of your comments (just because someone doesn't have the same opinion on a certain movie as yours, that doesn't make it so that they're 'wrong')

I was thinking about facts and directing in that way, not opinions and I did not say that he is "wrong". If that is his choice it is his choice.

I agree with what you say, Corvinus. I know you talk about something very real and hard, but you may have been aggressive with that "Have you ever been hungry from not having in life? Have you ever seen real people dying from starvation?" and what followed this.

I did not see it as agressive but it depends maybe on perception and personality, thought of it more down to a point when it comes to seeing some things are not so black and white, because someone saying about this things lightly seems to be in deep state of ignorance thinking like it is a walk in the park. So I am in a way suprised because he experienced some things firsthand and still clinges to some system beliefs.

Tell me please, corvinus, do you think you are not being used?

Of course I am and I am a slave but some things can be minimazed. Markets and other things are different story and I understand we have no choice in many things.

They can know if you steal them and they can make your life miserable. But maybe you would enjoy taking a big fine, just because you don't want to let them use you.

In my country it is different, everybody does it and nobody got fines, but I heared in some other countries they get them, but now we are in EU so things will be different in the near futur maybe. And yes I would not pay fine because I would not have from where, probably would get community service work or maybe even jail time.

es, I have been! You have a big lack of external consideration Corvinus. My family could barely manage to sustain itself, living in Romania was hard as hell. At one point we didn't have anything else to eat but bread and jam. My life wasn't easy at all.
And yes I saw real people, that didn't have nothing to eat, staying in outside in the winter.

I am sorry you experienced it, but still bit of suprised as mentioned above because it sounds like that program incorporated as a kid - be a good boy, work hard, do not steal, play by the book, be happy with less, etc... like those churchmen and priests say to people while doing 180° opposite. So I do not really feel guilty for watching a movie.

In the end it was not worth the time and energy for such trivial thing, because some do not understand others get emotional and start twisting things and it ends up running in circles like always with humans.
 
Oxajil said:
Hi edgitarra I understand your reasons that you are against downloading or watching movies online, what I don't understand is that at the same time you advertise a certain network and that they're ''the most visited website in the world and also stream movies online''. Why would you do that?
I thought it was a really well made movie, and couldn't stop the urge of telling also about the website. I am sorry, won't do it again, ever.

Also, Corvinus, you've been rude in some of your comments (just because someone doesn't have the same opinion on a certain movie as yours, that doesn't make it so that they're 'wrong'). Also, your comments towards edgitarra could've been worded differently. And edgitarra you seem to be biting back with your comment here: ''because in the way you try to read "me" you pretty much fail at doing it. Maybe practice more at that." Please try to be more civil with each other.

Yes, we shall be civilized, and respect each other.

Edit=Quote
 
What is right action? When am I acting within my moral boundaries and when am I transgressing them? And if I do something that to me is morally wrong, how do I justify this to myself?

These are some very interesting questions and in my personal experience there's definitely been a development in how I look at these things over the past years as a consequence of the Work and participating on this Forum. In the following I'll give some examples of how this has changed for me.

The question of downloading movies, music and software is a natural place to start. I used to download cracked versions of software, ripped movies or music and feel as a freedom fighter trying to overthrow the system. I would justify this to myself and others by arguing that the reason I was doing this was that the industry had failed to come up with a fair business model. And the fact that I was paying a monthly fee of $ 10 to be part of a newsgroup where a lot of pirated movies/software/music was available was the proof that I didn't mind paying if the price was right. This has changed somewhat but not entirely. I now pay for all my software except Microsoft products. Why? It's easy to come up with arguments such as Microsoft being a billion dollar evil empire and it'll make no difference to them whether I pay or not. There are other ways I can justify this to myself. However, the fact remains that I am still stealing their product. There are free alternatives available such as Linux for OS and OpenOffice for word processing and spread sheets. The true reason is that I don't feel I can afford the Microsoft products but even that's a justification because I can afford SRT sessions with Patrick Rodriguez so what it comes down to is that I'm unwilling to pay the price and the discomfort of doing this particular thing that I believe is morally wrong is not great enough compared to my STS gain from doing it. As I mentioned, there has been a development and I have stopped downloading books and most software but there's still a ways to go.

For me, it's been a change of being aware of what is morally OK for me. Another area where this has become evident is obeying traffic laws. I would always obey for instance red lights driving a car but on my bike or on foot I used to put myself over the law and cross a red light if I deemed that there was no danger. I would feel free and empowered. What consequences my actions had on other people in traffic was not very prominent in my awareness. Then one day I was going for a walk with another Forum member and with no cars in sight he stopped at a red light. That made me reflect on my own actions and I came to the conclusion that breaking the traffic laws was not something that was OK with me anymore. This is not to say that I've become a saint :). For instance I was late for a job interview some time ago and let the desire to be on-time supersede the value of not breaking the traffic law. However, I was aware that I was doing something that wasn't quite right but things aren't always black and white.

Another area that has changed for me is how I speak. I used to use a lot of slang and be very "cutting edge" in the words I used. I would also swear a fair bit and use a lot of sarcasm. About a year and a half ago this started to feel wrong and as a result I try to be conscious of what words I use and chose words that describe what I'm trying to say to the greatest extent possible. I remember when I was younger, thinking about "grown-ups" who kept saying that one shouldn't swear, that they were so old-fashioned and that they should get with the times. But things have changed and the way I see it now is that words carry meaning and energy and the more precisely I'm able to use the right words, the less noise I introduce into my communication. Or put another way, the more closely I'm aligning myself to truth. The same thing goes for sarcasm. While sarcasm can indeed be clever and funny it's actually a way of critiquing someone or something without really saying it outright. So what's going on is that your words say one thing but the meaning you're trying to convey is the opposite. I live in Denmark where sarcasm is very cherished (much like the UK) and in many social settings you're viewed as more popular, witty and intelligent if you employ sarcasm in the way you speak. But what it then translates to is that by using sarcasm you're trying to become popular at someone else's expense which is a very STS action that lacks external consideration, OSIT.

As Oxajil points out there will always be exceptions and in any given situation you have to weigh what's most important to you. I believe that the more aligned you are to truth, the more clearly you will feel what is right and similarly, the more painful it will be for you to do anything else. Until we get there the best we can do is to monitor our actions and the justifications we make to others and to ourselves if we transgress our moral boundaries.

Oh, and regarding the movie, I quite share PoB's view. While the movie had some symbolism that can be applied to the world at large it was far to violent for my taste. That's another area that has changed. I can't watch a lot of violence and gore in movies anymore. It's like I've become too sensitive. I sometimes wonder whether this is a good thing or a bad thing.
 
I also thought this movie was a bit extreme in its violence, but then again it was not as bad as "The Road". These are definitely not movies to relax to.

In its over-the-top presentation of almost everyone on the train being insane in their own way, I think it can open some people's eyes to the fact that the same insanity can be found all around us.

Since almost everyone is emotionally sick and mentally insane to a good degree, the sickness has become 'normal' and is taken as "part of life". I thought that is something this movie highlighted pretty well.
 
Back
Top Bottom