The wind that shakes the barley

[Gary]

I love this film, not just because of my Irish heritage - but because it is still so relevant today. For Ireland in the '20's - I see Gaza, Ukraine, Syria etc today. It invokes such positive, powerful feelings and moves me deeply - from righteous anger to heartfelt tears. Every now and again, when I need a 'shock' - to get motivated, to DO, this film reignites my 'fire inside'.

From Amazon.co.uk:

Winner of the Palme d'Or at the 2006 Cannes Film Festival, this gripping drama by Ken Loach (Raining Stones) is set during the early days of the Irish Republican Army, when British occupation of the Irish radicalised many a citizen and caused some to take up arms. Cillian Murphy plays Damien, a medical student on his way to London when he witnesses a couple of atrocities committed by British troops. Instead of becoming a doctor, he turns into a leading and respected figure in an IRA division led by his brother, Teddy (Padraic Delaney).

The film provides some fascinating historical insight into the nascent resistance movement as it was in 1920, and Loach brilliantly conveys the profound emotional transition young men had to make to become saboteurs and killers. Loach's realistic style is absolutely mesmerizing, with many scenes built around the dynamics of large groups: contentious meetings, torture sessions, battles, celebrations, and the like. One has the sense of history as a pool of energy, and one also develops a kind of Renoir-esque appreciation for the fact that different people on opposing sides of a life-or-death issue have their reasons for believing what they believe. As the story moves along, subtle shifts in the perspectives of men and women who had once agreed to be absolute in their fight for freedom results in a tragic yet understandable schism among Irish patriots. The final half-hour of The Wind That Shakes The Barley says a lot about how the Irish, including people who had known one another all their lives, turned their wrath on one another for so many decades. This is an outstanding film, featuring the best performance yet by Murphy (Red Eye). --Tom Keogh

Product Description

Political drama from veteran British filmmaker Ken Loach. Damien (Cillian Murphy) is about to leave Ireland for his medical studies in London while his brother Teddy (Padraic Delaney) is an active IRA member. After witnessing an act of resistance to the daily violence of the 'Black and Tans', Damien abandons his burgeoning career and joins his brother in a dangerous and violent fight for freedom. Eventually, both sides agree to a treaty to end the bloodshed. But, despite the apparent victory, civil war erupts and families who fought side by side, find themselves pitted against one another as sworn enemies, putting their loyalties to the ultimate test.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Wind-That-Shakes-Barley/dp/B000XSNCCW


This youtube video uses clips from the film and one of the moving songs featured, Óró Sé Beatha 'Bhaile sung by Sinead O'Connor

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ng7hOiaC2Zk&feature=player_detailpage

the fact that different people on opposing sides of a life-or-death issue have their reasons for believing what they believe

This seems to be legitimizing the conflict somewhat, taking the 'middle ground' position. It looks very clear to me. One country 'Ireland' was trying to defend itself against a foreign occupying force, the 'British'.

This reminded me of a recent excellent SOTT article: The "Middle Ground" Fallacy in Gaza

This is what is commonly referred to as the "middle ground fallacy", where it is assumed that the middle position between two extremes must be correct simply because it is the middle position...........There is a fundamental truth to the conflict in Gaza; the situation is not "complicated". The waters are further muddied, however, when one side of the argument is psychopathic, meaning completely devoid of human conscience. In this case, the middle ground fallacy only serves to further the psychopathic agenda. Any time an arbitrator invokes the middle ground, the psychopathic agenda is furthered and the truth is set back..................And this brings up another fundamental issue with the common perspective on the Israel-Gaza conflict - the woeful lack of education about the existence and actions of psychopaths.

http://www.sott.net/article/282920-The-Middle-Ground-Fallacy-in-Gaza