Hello,
I wanted first to precise that i do not at all follow the topic about Tartaria, but as i felt on a X post about this, i was a little bit intriguided, so i read the few comments and arrived to this video of 15 minutes. I verified if already posted (at least this copy of the video) and did not find, so, FWIW and for those who are "working" on this topic, this video may be interresting ... i don't know
This is an excellent video to show how the "Tataria Psy-op" works.
The audience is "targeted" from the beginning. English speaking, Christian right of center viewers. You have two authoritative speakers to that demographic (Putin and Carlson). The beginning of the video is a short summation of Russia conquering the Golden Horde in central and eastern Northern Asia - all of that makes sense and is backed up by sources. But then, the presenter interjects that
"Viewers on this channel know the Golden Horde as Greater Tartaria". That's not what Putin said. That's what the You Tuber said.
Greater Tartary, is a term from Encyclopedia Britannica - not Russia. The Golden Horde or the Khanates of the the Golden Horde is more accurate. The wars between Kazan and the Russian Empire happened (both sides consider them defining historical battles for Tatars and Russians).
But the presenter is completely ignoring the historical records of Kazan (Tataristan), the Ottoman's, Persia etc. These central Asian city-states were inherited from Genghis Khan's original conquest. Many records in many languages all confirm this. The Golden Horde were a loosely connected series of city-sates and regions throughout the vast expanse of Central Asia with Mongol
overlords. The populations weren't "Mongol" per se, but Turkic people genetically related to each other. Much of the general population had no cultural connection the Mongols. See Tengritism and how it was used as a control measure to weaken Islam, Christianity and Shamanic beliefs. Blood sacrifices at a state level are remarkably effective in prolongining a dying empire.
Later on, the discussion of the erasure of "Mongol" records to be replaced by "Russian Christian" records by of all people, Stalin, contradicts the narrative. I've seen many travelogues in Kazan and I don't think there is any erasure anymore. Without a doubt there were communist purges of history in the USSR, but Kazan seems pretty confident in its buildings and tours of its Mongol/Tatarian past.
The argument the presenter makes is that an 1825 textbook in America claimed that the Tatarians traced their history back, not to Genghis Khan, but to Noah's son, Japhet. Then he throws in that the Rockefeller's banned it some decades later. A common theme.
Anyone familiar with western psyops can see where this is going. It was a given that the Old Testament was actual history in the 1800's in Revivalist America. The idea that all of these patriarchs of Tartary, Mongol, Altai world came from the Levant with a mission to start a grand civilization that never happened in Judea - it's nuts.
There is a common theme in these Pysops for the North American conspiracy consumer who is right of center:
Lost Civilization in Asia that was once worldwide - known by Americans who studied the Bible in the 1800's - erased by Russian communists - found out to be the truth by YouTubers in the past ten years - confirmed by Putin in 2024.
Now Putin will release the "Taratry Files". The truth will be revealed. The Bible is actual history. Who wrote the Bible? All civilization comes from Noah's sons. So maybe Israel should be in charge of the planet. Or maybe their handlers...
This video is ultra-sophisticated. The presenter blurs lines in the linguistic field between completely different language groups and makes it sound convincing. He also convincingly conflates external records on the Mongol invasions with much later Ottoman records (both were Turkic - both were enemies) and makes it seem like there's a seamless connection between Genghis and the Ottoman's - when in fact they had completely different concepts of ruler ship.
His argument that "Conventional Historians" have zero records of the Golden Horde calling themselves that means that they were Tartarians (meaning no connection the the Mongols) is amazing. It would be like saying no records ever naming Germany as Germany are accurate. Only records describing the history of Deustschland happened.
There's a lot more in this video that is really mind-blowing. It is not the work of an amateur "conspiracy theorist". There are shades of "The Grand Chessboard" in the presentation and multiple CIA talking points. With the production values and complexity of "muddy waters" presented from a wholly western point of view it amazes me how much work went into this.
It would seem that someone somewhere in very high places wants an ancient civilization to be "resurrected" as the true civilization.
The one quote that points to this is,
"If the Tartaria coverup was to be exposed, it would completely re-frame the power structure of contemporary civilization".
Sounds a little "undergrounder" to me...
If this was a serious attempt at revealing a lost civilization, why is there no archaeology going on? Why isn't there a bunch of YouTube or Telegram channels with Tatars and Russians showing anomalous civilization relics? I see a lot of Tatar travelogues and conversely a lot of megalithic Siberian explorations. But somehow the heart of Grand Tartary (always spelt wrong in the west) in Kazan - there's no discussion?