mamadrama
The Living Force
Just on a practical note, the potential for abuse in DNA profiling, IMO is too great.
How do you keep the data secure? Obviously the data would be stored on a computer system, available to law enforcement personnel. If the DNA information is treated like all other personal information, a private company will get the contract to store the information and require passwords for law enforcement personal to access that information.
One has only to glance at the news, to know that there is not a database in the world that cannot have its data stolen.
Lynch, one of the leading proponents for a DNA database in SA cited in the article Erna posted says this:
Remember the slew of data losses in the UK over the past couple of years?
It's unlikely that DNA profiling is a crime deterrent. If capital punishment doesn't deter crime, it's not likely DNA profiling will either. It seems to be just one more step toward control which eventually infringes on all people's rights. Sure, let's start with the populations who have no voice, the criminals and the babies, but before long it will be used on everyone, osis.
Newborns Targeted for DNA Profiling
Could you make a genetically targeted weapon?
How do you keep the data secure? Obviously the data would be stored on a computer system, available to law enforcement personnel. If the DNA information is treated like all other personal information, a private company will get the contract to store the information and require passwords for law enforcement personal to access that information.
One has only to glance at the news, to know that there is not a database in the world that cannot have its data stolen.
Lynch, one of the leading proponents for a DNA database in SA cited in the article Erna posted says this:
Lynch is passionate about the use of DNA in investigating crime. She maintains that a database of DNA profiles would allow the police to identify suspects, link and work out the modus operandi of syndicates, and eventually streamline the handling of criminal cases.
Her research and recent visit to the national DNA database in Britain one of the biggest in the world - has convinced her that the development can lead only to increased success.
Remember the slew of data losses in the UK over the past couple of years?
Banks in Britain are required under the Data Protection Act to keep personal information secure. But banking and other sensitive information increasingly is being lost.
Last year, Nationwide Building Society was fined nearly £1 million ($2.6 million) after a laptop containing private customer data was stolen from an employee's home.
The breach comes after several high profile cases involving the loss of data by government agencies. Last week, a contractor lost a memory device containing information on prison inmates in England and Wales and in June, two sets of secret government files on terror tactics were left on commuter trains.
The most dramatic data loss occurred in November when tax officials admitted they had lost computer discs containing banking information on 25 million people - nearly half the country's population.
It's unlikely that DNA profiling is a crime deterrent. If capital punishment doesn't deter crime, it's not likely DNA profiling will either. It seems to be just one more step toward control which eventually infringes on all people's rights. Sure, let's start with the populations who have no voice, the criminals and the babies, but before long it will be used on everyone, osis.
Newborns Targeted for DNA Profiling
Could you make a genetically targeted weapon?