I
Iain McKie
Guest
Beware our rapidly developing surveillance society as evidenced by the proposed European Fingerprint Database.
While tackling crime and terrorism is important the present love affair with biometrics, technology and government control is leading to a situation where each and every one of us is in genuine danger of being accused of a crime we did not commit.
In the UK we have always had an undue regard for the ‘infallibility’ of experts but more and more cases are showing that they can be very fallible and that injustice is all the harder to fight if your guilt is supported on so called ‘expert evidence.’
Another major issue is the lack of standardisation of fingerprint experts across the world. From country to country they work to different standards and quality control varies greatly.
For over 10 years fingerprint experts in Scotland have been denying that they made two mistakes that brought my daughter to the edge of suicide and condemned a young man to a life sentence.
Although she has been totally vindicated and he released from prison the experts continue with their denials.
Unfortunately in our surveillance society when the technology delivers its verdict we are relying on such experts to prove our innocence.
The full story of my daughter’s experience can be found at www(dot)shirleymckie.com
Before creating such vast databases let's ensure that the necessary safeguards are built into the system.
While tackling crime and terrorism is important the present love affair with biometrics, technology and government control is leading to a situation where each and every one of us is in genuine danger of being accused of a crime we did not commit.
In the UK we have always had an undue regard for the ‘infallibility’ of experts but more and more cases are showing that they can be very fallible and that injustice is all the harder to fight if your guilt is supported on so called ‘expert evidence.’
Another major issue is the lack of standardisation of fingerprint experts across the world. From country to country they work to different standards and quality control varies greatly.
For over 10 years fingerprint experts in Scotland have been denying that they made two mistakes that brought my daughter to the edge of suicide and condemned a young man to a life sentence.
Although she has been totally vindicated and he released from prison the experts continue with their denials.
Unfortunately in our surveillance society when the technology delivers its verdict we are relying on such experts to prove our innocence.
The full story of my daughter’s experience can be found at www(dot)shirleymckie.com
Before creating such vast databases let's ensure that the necessary safeguards are built into the system.