Before Easter, I went to a garden center to buy some flowers for my garden. As I was leaving the store and loading the flowers into my car, a woman approached me asking for money, saying she wanted to buy food. I get approached by people asking for money at stores a few times a year. Since I was on my way to the grocery store, I offered to bring her some food if she had nothing to eat. She agreed. In the store, I bought her the food she asked for, plus a little extra. I also tucked 20 euros into the bag. Somehow, I felt a sense of guilt for not wanting to give her the cash directly. What if she really needed it? I handed her the bag of food, muttered a comment hoping she wouldn't have to do this again next time, and drove off.
The first thing that crossed my mind once I was back in the car was what a stupid thing I had said. I didn't understand it. Immediately after, it occurred to me that this same thing had happened before. A sense of déjà vu—an identical situation from about ten years ago, with the same woman and the same store. Even back then, ten years ago, I had acted in exactly the same way.
On the way home, I felt unsettled. I couldn't understand why. I spent the entire drive analyzing the situation and arrived at this conclusion: I could have just given her the money as she asked—maybe she would have bought food, maybe alcohol, it’s hard to say. Internally, I don't want to support or provide money for things that aren't good, like alcohol or drugs, and that was the reason I initially refused. I ended up buying her the food she asked for and even tucked the money she wanted into the bag, so I should have felt good about it. I hoped it was a good deed. But it wasn't. I just realized that not giving her the money would have likely left me feeling like a selfish and heartless person if she truly needed help. Yet, when I do give her the money, I still don't feel good—presumably because I have the feeling that she is exploiting many other people in this way. That it isn't sincere, and ultimately, it doesn't even solve the woman's situation.
I feel that this situation has no solution in terms of whether to give or not to give, because both options lead me to a bad feeling. It seems to me that the solution would be to maintain distance, which I didn't do, and subsequently, I was so tired and exhausted for two days that I couldn't do anything but lie down and rest. Another thing was that I looked the woman in the eyes, and after that, I felt uncomfortable inside. I don’t know, perhaps one needs to be more cautious about whom we look in the eyes.
I would be grateful for your insights and ideas. Have a lovely evening.