eternusphoenix said:
Maybe I'm missing something here or maybe I just can't see the whole picture. How can a person caught in a war zone (Palestine, Iraq, Afganistan, or the ghettos all over the world) possibly apply these principles and have any degree of success? It seems to me that these principles are most easily applied in affluent nations.
Hmm, I don't think so. We all have our lives according to the lessons we chose to learn and the environment we chose to be in, on a certain level. And in every life, I think, opportunities will open up for people to learn how to Give and how to Receive in a natural and external considerate way. Poor people in the countries you mentioned can always be creative in their own way, small or big. They can help themselves and their families with gaining money (maybe even get creative and selling artworks or poems), they can help with cooking, they can help children cope with the reality they're in, and some might even start organizations or simply start a newspaper to spread their current knowledge of what is going on in their country. Success doesn't always mean, having lots of money.
Nobody is a nobody, and everyone can do something to make their lives richer, in whatever aspect that is suitable for them at the time of being and the place and circumstances they're in.
eternusphoenix said:
Isn't nature simply a mechanical organism that via it's own genetic code continues to reproduce for it's own survival? All living things have within their genetic code the impulse to reproduce but I don't see that as giving, I see that as survival of the machine.
I think there are many levels to it. Think about the Universe as infinite, think about the idea that souls live through all Creation in an infinite way, from start to end, from end to start, like an endless cycle, where death is merely a part of Nature, too. If there is such infinity, the main idea to do things solely to reproduce sounds limiting. Surely reproducing is part of Nature as well, and the same goes for survival, it's biology. But I don't think that's all there is. What about the ''drive'' to grow spiritually, to reconnect with Nature, or to simply learn the lessons we are here to learn?
eternusphoenix said:
I'm confused because I thought after having read ISOTM that EVERYTHING is simply mechanical (until mechanical man struggles for a very long time to BE something else and to be able to DO). Laura's above quote emotionally feels good but how is it true?
Think about the people who don't know about Gurdjieff. Many people go into therapy, and learn a lot about themselves, whether little or great things, some other people learn other things, maybe they learn to be independent, maybe they learn that being very selfish in certain aspects in their life isn't fruitful for others and themselves, so something
is happening. We all learn, with the knowlegde we have, with the choices we make, in our own way and at our own pace. Just because everything and everyone is mechanical, doesn't necessarily mean that there is absolutely no opportunity for progress (or success/richness). So on one level, everything merely happens and everything and everyone is mechanical, but on another level there might be struggle and learning going on, too. And for those who actively work on themselves in a network like this, with the knowledge we have, some people might learn certain things faster than people who don't have such things. But yea, it depends.
eternusphoenix said:
To someone who reads this (who is NOT involved in any esoteric work) and attempts to apply this, wouldn't the results amount to repeating mantras and dreaming of this possible reality?
Maybe and maybe not. It would depend on the person, I think. Maybe someone who is not involved in esoteric work could realize from reading this that asking money for one's efforts doesn't have to be a bad thing. Or maybe someone will go about dreaming, as you say, and totally misunderstand and not achieve anything. There are many possibilities I think.
For what it's worth.
Interesting questions, by the way, eternusphoenix!