Hopefully this will set a precedent for other reckless parents out there, at least in Florida, who force feed their babies and little kids on vegan diets and the like.
In Europe, in 2016 in Italy, politician Elvira Savino, a member of Berlusconi´s party at that time,
proposed a bill making it possible to punish
“reckless” vegan parents with jail time for raising their children on restrictive diets. This was based on some cases coming to light where children were hospitalized with malnutrition.
Everybody and his dog fell over her and it goes without saying that the bill didn´t make it into law.
The reason, as i understand, was that the door would be open for
stigmatizing other parents — those who have overweight children for instance. So parents must not be
made to feel bad, nothing to do with protecting the health of vulnerable little kids. Where have we heard that before?
Some cases i found in Europe go to show that there really is not much legal punishment for severely abusing/causing death of your children in this way.
In 2019 in Sweden an 18 month old baby almost died after having been force fed a vegan diet by her parents. Doctors said if the baby had been brought to hospital only hours later, she would have been dead. Prosecutors asked for 3 years in jail on the basis of ´severe neglect´and putting the child in ´life-threatening situation´. They got
3 months in jail and the child went to a foster home. The parents had very strange views of reality, according to the judge, but had had no harmful intent toward her.
In 2017, a Belgian court "convicted" parents with the
minimum of 6 months suspended, over the death of their 7 month old baby who died of malnutrition and dehydration with organs shrunk to half their size and without any fat around them. Imagine that! Judge Mieke Butstraen said the demise of the baby was “the result of the systematic offer of food that was not suitable.” But, in the opinion of the judge their sentence of 6 months suspended was more than enough, because “It is clear that the defendants have already been severely punished because they need to proceed with life in the knowledge that they are responsible for the death of their son,
who they truly loved,” Butstraen said.
In
Australia, parents avoided jail but got
300 hours of community service after their toddler was so malnourished that her bones fractured and teeth fell out.
Unlike the Florida court, the states featured above certainly do not seem to take their role as protector of the vulnerable minors very seriously when parents frightfully fall short.