Why can't the English be more like the French?

Johnno

The Living Force
This delightful article can be found here:

http://www.sott.net/articles/show/143067-Why-can-t-the-English-be-more-like-the-French-

Having been to both and being a somewhat impartial third party observer I feel a I am free to make some comparisons between the "Froggies" and the "Rosbifs" (Roast beefs).

Travelling several glum, silent, tube rides on the London Underground, there was a feeling of, "These people are so bloody repressed!" and reading my freebie newspaper; I found several ads for those who had made brief fleeting contact with the opposite sex and had done nothing about it. They were now desperate to make contact again. As Roger Waters put it "Living in quiet desperation is the English way."

CCTV's seem to be everywhere and Canary Wharf is probably the most soul-less, god-forsaken canyon of concrete and glass I've ever been. The class (dare I say caste) divide is woefully apparent.

And the funniest quote I've come across about the French from an English perspective is from Top Gear's James May.

France is a country you have to drive through to get to Italy. That’s all it’s for. They are a bunch of treacherous, lamb-burning, work-shy peasants.
The class system again and the live to work rule....see?

There again, from my perspective there are things which the English seem to do much better than the French.

The "quiet desperation" seems to lead to an groundswell from time to time which leads to an explosion in cultural, artistic and musical output. The Beatles emerged from the Merseyside, Joy Division and New Order from Manchester, Pink Floyd from the Psychedelic 60's, Led Zeppelin in the hard rocking 70's, The Sex Pistols and The Clash in the punk age. And then there's others Bowie, Eno, Radiohead, The Chemical Brothers.

The English oddity of the "eccentric" seem to be alive and well and the well known English tolerance seems to treat these with a sort of nonchalance. The little guy on London Bridge who sets up his makeshift souvenir stand is politely shooed away by English Bobbies every day at seven o'clock. He still comes back again and again.

The only two countries that seem to have a reverence for tea seem to be island countries..... Japan and England. You could probably add Ireland to that list too. The French can't do tea, adding boiling water just doesn't compute for some strange reason. And both England and France don't seem to be able to do really good coffee, only the Italians can do that. As one Italian friend said to me as we were sharing a coffee in France which was semi drinkable, "You would be taken outside and shot if you made coffe like this in Italy."

There's something to be said for a British breakfast too. It is really something that has to be experienced before one dies. Order a British breakfast in France and it pales by comparison. Much like English crepes are nothing compared to the delightful fluffiness of a well made French variety which the article refers to.

The French tend to put up a new building and then let it deteriorate from there. Charles de Gaul no 2 airport being the best example of this (which is terrible). The rows of gleaming Victorian houses in a row that have been maintained and look like new seems to be rare. Pieces of flaking off stucco and crumbling bricks seem to regarded as "charming".Oak beamed Tudor shops in Salisbury look as if they were put up yesterday.

The French bureaucracy is horrific. A friend who was trying to transfer money between accounts had to go into the bank, get a paniced look from the next manager up and finally go into an office and sign the documents with the bank manager's approval. A process that would be well covered by a few clicks from the comfort of ones office in England.

So what do both countries do well?

I found the abilty to move large amounts of people around were excellent. The Metro and the Underground are superb. The autoroutes and motorways are also wonderful and both cultures seem to drive extremely well.

Both countries also seem to have a knack of mixing the new with the old. The Gherkin and the Geogres Pompidou seem right in place in their one-time Roman fortress cities. Both seem to have a reverence for the past. The English may be a little stronger in this regard with their "people run" National Trust which seems to have little reminders everywhere.

And a healthy respect for the outdoors seems to be strong in both cultures too. Stands of oak trees and forest seem to have escaped the bulldozer in both countries. Canals are now utilised by holiday barges which is wonderful.

Engineering and innovation seems to be strong as well although the English seem to have "sold the farm" to a certain degree. Jaguar, Mini, Rolls Royce and Bentley all now in overseas hands. Renault Peugeot and Airbus still remaing quintessentially French.
 
The article makes a lot of comparisons with the superficial aspects of life, but I wouldn't disagree that France is a better place to live.
I agree with your observations. The UK is a soulless place nowadays and unfortunately a few decent music bands doesn't make up for the complete lack of community and self-serving lifestyle. At least in France there seems to be some balance between work, family and leisure time and there isn't the vacuous 'all or nothing' social scene that the UK has, which seems to be getting worse. It's not surprising more people want to 'escape' from the drudgery of longer working hours and more expensive standards of living.
At the end of the day, if people stopped believing the lies coming from the psychopaths in power and realised we have a choice in all this, that 'they' have very different ideas as to what consitutes life than the majority of people in the world, people could begin to choose to live the way they'd really like to. Sorry if I got a bit off topic..
 
Johnno said:
The only two countries that seem to have a reverence for tea seem to be island countries..... Japan and England. You could probably add Ireland to that list too.
Nicely written perspective Johnno, but I have to disagree about your comments on tea. Japanese tea bears no resemblance to English tea, and the Irish only drink English tea to remind them of their colonial past, "lest we forget" (although it is common practice to make it more palatable by adding a shot of Whiskey).

The English practice of corrupting decent tea leaves by adding milk is an abomination. There is also something disturbing about the English art of tea drinking. You may have noticed that the cup of tea appears to be a filler for, or better said a distraction from, those unavoidable awkward moments in the daily lives of English people when their deeply repressed emotions threaten to surface. There is the uncomfortable silence, immediately followed by "do you want a cup of tea?" Phew! Thank god for that!

I believe therefore that if English people were to take the difficult and painful step of throwing off the tradition of drinking tea every five minutes, they may as a result contribute significantly to the saving of their very souls.

Joe

N.B. No English people were harmed in the process of conducting background research for this opinion. I cannot however guarantee that none were irked by the voicing of it. ;-)
 
Joe said:
I believe therefore that if English people were to take the difficult and painful step of throwing off the tradition of drinking tea every five minutes, they may as a result contribute significantly to the saving of their very souls.
:lol:

the other day I went for a full 10 minutes without drinking a cup of tea, and so came right to the very brink of saving my soul.

But then the tea urge kicked in, and all was lost.
 
I don't want to ruin your fun (and it IS a funny discussion ;) ) just wanted to remind you that tea has high levels of fluoride in it.

So...sleepyvinny, those 10 minutes without tea probably helped you to stay awake a little longer. ;)

(I hope you didn't spit your tea all over the keyboard (like I did...well, a little) after reading first time about this ground shaking information :)

And tea with milk is indeed an abomination.

Joe said:
Japanese tea bears no resemblance to English tea, and the Irish only drink English tea to remind them of their colonial past, "lest we forget" (although it is common practice to make it more palatable by adding a shot of Whiskey).
You mean Irish cream, or just whiskey without cream?
 
Russians drink tea, too, and they are not an island country.

The generalization I heard is that tea countries don't do wine and wine countries don't do tea.
 
Joe said:
Johnno said:
The only two countries that seem to have a reverence for tea seem to be island countries..... Japan and England. You could probably add Ireland to that list too.
Nicely written perspective Johnno, but I have to disagree about your comments on tea. Japanese tea bears no resemblance to English tea, and the Irish only drink English tea to remind them of their colonial past, "lest we forget" (although it is common practice to make it more palatable by adding a shot of Whiskey).
Is there anything the Irish don't put whiskey in?

Yes the tea is different but the "ritual" I suppose is still there, albeit in a less formal form. Each of these "workings" of the tea ritual seem to be equally important, otherwise the Magnum Opus is ruined.

Warm the teapot, add the tea leaves plus "one for the pot", pour in the boiling water, let it stand for the correct time (under a Union Jack tea cosy) then serve it through a strainer in some fine bone china and silverware. The stirring of the tea and finall "clink, clink, clink" of tapping the teaspoon (on the edge of your finest Wedgewood), is reminiscent of the Sanctus Bell in Mass at the completion of transubstantiation. The water and dried leaves have been magically transformed into a fortifying brew.

Joe said:
The English practice of corrupting decent tea leaves by adding milk is an abomination. There is also something disturbing about the English art of tea drinking. You may have noticed that the cup of tea appears to be a filler for, or better said a distraction from, those unavoidable awkward moments in the daily lives of English people when their deeply repressed emotions threaten to surface. There is the uncomfortable silence, immediately followed by "do you want a cup of tea?" Phew! Thank god for that!
The milk deal would make me a sinner then! It seems to be common downunder, a hangover from our colonial past.

Yes, I think you're right on the awkward moments deal. I saw an interview with John Cleese and he described how the English aim was to make it to one's deathbed without ever being embarrassed. "Phew, made it through that one all right.".

However if emotions are need to be expressed they have their little safety valves all over the island in the form of the English pub.

Joe said:
I believe therefore that if English people were to take the difficult and painful step of throwing off the tradition of drinking tea every five minutes, they may as a result contribute significantly to the saving of their very souls.

Joe
Amen!

Joe said:
N.B. No English people were harmed in the process of conducting background research for this opinion. I cannot however guarantee that none were irked by the voicing of it. ;-)
A most important addendum!
 
Keit said:
I don't want to ruin your fun (and it IS a funny discussion ;) ) just wanted to remind you that tea has high levels of fluoride in it.

So...sleepyvinny, those 10 minutes without tea probably helped you to stay awake a little longer. ;)

(I hope you didn't spit your tea all over the keyboard (like I did...well, a little) after reading first time about this ground shaking information :)

And tea with milk is indeed an abomination.

Joe said:
Japanese tea bears no resemblance to English tea, and the Irish only drink English tea to remind them of their colonial past, "lest we forget" (although it is common practice to make it more palatable by adding a shot of Whiskey).
You mean Irish cream, or just whiskey without cream?
Just Whiskey, you should try it!

Joe
 
Ahhhh Tea!

I wake up each morning , unfortunately not in a way Gurdjieff would like me to , and I make myself a cup of tea.

With milk!

Then its coffee for the rest of the day usually.Both drinks come without whiskey as it tends to put hairs on the back of my teeth.

The teapot comes out here only on rare moments spurred on by god knows what and as im a northern sub working class peasant i drink it from a mug , jam jar , a shoe or anything to hand. No union jack is to be found in my houshold as im not English , i´m from Liverpool. and have a scouse / Liverpool passport to prove it.

(Scouse Passport is a fun passport for the state of Merseyside which was produced by Liverpool council and Merseyside Tourist Authority in the 1980’s)
 
Joe said:
Just Whiskey, you should try it!
Well, as it so happens, I have a bottle of Glenfiddich Single Malt on my desk which may prove useful in an experiment to determine the objectivity of the above statement. Tea + Whiskey is a mixture unknown to me as yet, so I shall have to observe closely. Repeat measures may be required to verify the result.

Purely in the name of science, of course.
 
Ryan said:
Joe said:
Just Whiskey, you should try it!
Well, as it so happens, I have a bottle of Glenfiddich Single Malt on my desk which may prove useful in an experiment to determine the objectivity of the above statement. Tea + Whiskey is a mixture unknown to me as yet, so I shall have to observe closely. Repeat measures may be required to verify the result.

Purely in the name of science, of course.
It's much better if you use Irish whiskey! It's made to go in tea.
 
Ryan said:
Joe said:
Just Whiskey, you should try it!
Well, as it so happens, I have a bottle of Glenfiddich Single Malt on my desk which may prove useful in an experiment to determine the objectivity of the above statement. Tea + Whiskey is a mixture unknown to me as yet, so I shall have to observe closely. Repeat measures may be required to verify the result.

Purely in the name of science, of course.
No doubt. :cool2:

I think I am going to help Ryan with an experiment, but use Jameson instead. And repeat measures are must if you want it to be a proper scientific experiment (however there may be a slight change in margin of error after a first cup ;) )
 
Laura said:
It's much better if you use Irish whiskey! It's made to go in tea.
I don't have any Jameson's on hand, so I'll just have to purchase a bottle tomorrow for the tea experiment. Oh, the pain of it all... :lol:

Keit said:
I think I am going to help Ryan with an experiment, but use Jameson instead. And repeat measures are must if you want it to be a proper scientific experiment (however there may be a slight change in margin of error after a first cup ;) )
Ahh... excellent, Keit. It is good scientific method to have another independent laboratory repeat the experiment for verification. :D
 
I thought whiskey is what people meant when they talk about tea :shock: Realizing I was wrong isn't going to change how I handle "tea time" :lol:

Maybe if the British switched to whiskey (instead of hot beer) they'd wake up a bit and stopping letting their government turn their country into a gerbal cage.
 
Back
Top Bottom