James M. McCanney - Plasma Discharge Comet Theory

  • Thread starter Thread starter Arlo_usa
  • Start date Start date
While reading the latest piece by Laura, http://www.sott.net/articles/show/221265-Not-Ready-To-Make-Nice#commentnotice I searched for Prof. James McCanney and found a few clips of a talk he gave at at conference: Cutting Edge Show #29 - Prof. James McCanney - Comets + Our Electric Universe
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=999435651090748119#

In the youtube one can watch illustrations of how a comet can interact with the sun. The clips with comets are a few minutes before halfway through.
 
thorbiorn said:
While reading the latest piece by Laura, http://www.sott.net/articles/show/221265-Not-Ready-To-Make-Nice#commentnotice I searched for Prof. James McCanney and found a few clips of a talk he gave at at conference: Cutting Edge Show #29 - Prof. James McCanney - Comets + Our Electric Universe
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=999435651090748119#

In the youtube one can watch illustrations of how a comet can interact with the sun. The clips with comets are a few minutes before halfway through.

I enjoyed the McCanney parts, but the host guy was really kind of boring.
 
James Mc Canney

Just had a brief look at his website. Seems to cover many topics that would be of interest to Sott readers without the esoteric. There seems to be a lot more to him besides his work on comets etc. I don't want to post a link but just google him and it is an easy find.
 
Re: James Mc Canney

Hi aaron r, there is a thread that discusses James McCanney. There are other threads as well using the search function.
 
_http://sites.google.com/site/cosmologyquest/the-editor-s-musings/comets

This guy has a site that provides lots of evidence supporting McCanney's theories. He also has a series of videos that are pretty informative, if you can get over his nerdy voice and demeanor.

He includes information from NASA probes sent to comets showing that no comet has ever been found to contain significant amounts of ice.

Video (Part one of six): _http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dotIv6bJemE&feature=related
 
Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

From: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1351064/Japan-raises-alert-following-volcanos-biggest-eruption-50-years.html

A one-mile cordon has been established around a volcano on Mount Kirishima after it erupted scattering rocks and ash across southern Japan and sending smoke billowing 5,000ft into the air.

The Meteorological Agency raised the volcanic alert to level 3 as ash today continued to spew from Shinmoedake on Japan's southernmost main island of Kyushu, and residents have been banned from going within a mile of the volcano following its worst eruption in 50 years.

article-1351064-0CEF6C15000005DC-720_964x544.jpg

Is it just me or does it look like the lightning came from the volcano? Does anybody know if this is "normal" in the sense of being observed during other volcanic eruptions in the past?
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

I have seen lightening in a snow storm,
but never have seen lightening come from a hole in the ground and shoot up too the sky.!.!.!

If this is NOT normal, Something is perhaps changing with our BBM electrical charge.?.?.?
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

I know that thunderbolts in vulcanic eruptions are normal and I've seen it before.
this thunderbolt really looks awesome !
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

I believe it is not uncommon for lightning to take place during a volcanic eruption. There were many photos of lightning taking place during the eruption of Eyjafjallajökull in Iceland last year. The 'official' science explanation is that the process is not clearly understood. I recall James McCanney offering an explanation in one of his Science Hour broadcasts. I'll see if I can find it.
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

Definitely not uncommon. We saw one presentation where they recorded 70,000 strikes in a several hour period! This phenomenon has been being published at several conferences lately.

Here's a pertinent example:

http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2010/2010GL044208.shtml

ENJOY
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

Al Today said:
I have seen lightening in a snow storm,
but never have seen lightening come from a hole in the ground and shoot up too the sky.!.!.!

I have seen a lightning shoot up from the ground at night when there was no cloud covers around a couple of years ago - that was weird - and I thought it was something electrical that set it off but no where near the volcano.

And, in this case, that's just awesome picture of one, even if it's uncommon.
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

Thanks for the observation Myrddin Awyr
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

Potamus said:
Definitely not uncommon. We saw one presentation where they recorded 70,000 strikes in a several hour period! This phenomenon has been being published at several conferences lately.

Here's a pertinent example:

http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2010/2010GL044208.shtml

ENJOY

Interesting. I can only read the abstract, but it sounds like they're saying this is caused by the same mechanism that thunderclouds produce lightning; that is, through a separation of charge from particle collision.

To offer another perspective, here's what the Electric Universe folks have to say:

http://www.thunderbolts.info/tpod/2005/arch05/050131volcaniclightning.htm

Volcanic Lightning

The cause of volcanic lightning is not completely understood. Geologists assume that the cause is similar to the cause of lightning in thunderstorms. From an electric universe point of view, the Earth is a small charged body moving in a large cell of plasma, and there is charge waiting for a connection to it.

More than 150 times in the past two centuries, volcanic eruptions have been accompanied by spectacular displays of lightning. Sometimes broad bolts of lightning streak across the sky. Other times St. Elmo's fire (ball lightning) cascades from above. Sometimes volcanoes produce branching displays such as at Sakurajima (see photo above.) The 1981 eruption of Mt St Helens featured a spectacular display of sheet lightning, with truck-sized balls of St Elmo's fire seen rolling along the ground 29 miles north of the mountain. Other well-known volcanoes that produced lightning include Vesuvius (1944), Krakatau (1990's), Surtsey, the new volcanic island in Iceland (1963), and Paracutin, the cinder cone that grew out of a farmer's field in Mexico (1940's.)

The cause of volcanic lightning is not completely understood. Geologists assume that the cause is similar to the cause of lightning in thunderstorms, which is also not completely understood. [For discussion of lightning, see TPOD Sept 17, 2004, Weather: Fair, Foul and Electric] For years, geologists have talked about charge separation caused by volcanic dust particles colliding and building up static charges. Recently a new theory has been proposed that relies on the water content of magma.

From an electric universe point of view, the Earth is a small charged body moving in a large cell of plasma. Because of this, explanations of all physical phenomena in, on, and near the Earth must take the electrical behavior of plasma into account. The Physics of the Plasma Universe by Anthony Peratt describes magma as a plasma, a medium containing moving charges. So we should expect volcanoes not only to exhibit electrical behavior but to have that behavior connected with the larger plasma environment, that is, to be elements in a larger electrical circuit.

But why do some volcanoes produce lightning while others don't? More curious, why do some volcanoes with large dusty plumes produce little or no lightning and others with small or mediocre plumes produce much lightning? The simple answer could be that all volcanoes are electric but that the lightning displays happen only when the resistance to the volcanic current is high. You have a good example of this in your home. The electric wires that carry the current from the wall socket to your lamp don't produce heat or light. But when that same current encounters the high resistance of a tungsten filament, it does produce heat and light.

By studying the electrical component of volcanoes on Earth, plasma geologists can gather clues about the mysteries of Earth's volcanic geologic history. For example, it may help to explain why volcanism in the past -- the great basalt floods -- was hotter and more voluminous than in the present. And it may even help explain why Mars has volcanoes that are many times larger than any found on Earth today. Were Earth and Mars subjected to more powerful plasma interactions in the past?
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

The McCanney broadcast in which he talks briefly about volcanoes and lightning is from April 22, 2010, at about 36 minutes.

He doesn't go into much detail, but says that it is essentially the same electrical process which he maintains causes tornadoes and hurricanes, which is a discharge of excess positive charge in the ionosphere flowing to ground through a pathway provided by the energy of the storm or volcanic plume. Which in turn can cause subsequent discharges when elements in the storm, earth or plume gain surplus charge.
 
Re: Lightning and fire: Japan on alert after volcano's biggest eruption in 50 years

Here is a picture someone sent to me from the Christian Science Monitor from a couple days ago (unfortunately I don't have details about which volcano this was or when it happened):
 

Attachments

  • volcanolightning.jpg
    volcanolightning.jpg
    53.8 KB · Views: 6
Back
Top Bottom