This turned me upside down: Making one guy to believe that apocalypse 'happened'

AWTF said:
Choosing a stick as a possible weapon on the young girls suggestion ,made me wonder why he had not chosen to have something for his defence when there were zombie like things all over the place earlier.

I was worried that he was going to attack some of the zombies. If the show was real, how could they protect the fake zombies from being attacked? I know they told him to stay away because the disease is contagious but what if he had been watching Walking Dead and decided to start stabbing them?
 
At the very end, when Darren calls Steven on the phone and "puts him to sleep" watch how he falls down to the ground.

Of course if it wasn't a set-up and was actually real, making Steven fall to the ground like that could have been dangerous.
 
The question about this "documentary" being entirely staged is raging in the comments section on the Youtube links, tons of people thinks that indeed, this is obviously a "fake".

I have to agree for my own part that at no time, no time at all, we hear him "cursing", and that waved some red flag for me too. We have to see the fact that the whole thing was reaaaally clean about words, too clean, especially in such a "dirty" situation.
 
Ekios said:
The question about this "documentary" being entirely staged is raging in the comments section on the Youtube links, tons of people thinks that indeed, this is obviously a "fake".

I have to agree for my own part that at no time, no time at all, we hear him "cursing", and that waved some red flag for me too. We have to see the fact that the whole thing was reaaaally clean about words, too clean, especially in such a "dirty" situation.

It's a possibility that Mr Brown picked exactly the right character they needed for the show, someone passive, easily compliant who never took care of himself due to his narcissistic upbringing but we've only watched the first part so far though.
It seems like the guy needs to be directed somehow, even if he does not know it himself.
Moreover what other kind of priming did he get that we don't know about ?

Masamune said:
AWTF said:
Choosing a stick as a possible weapon on the young girls suggestion ,made me wonder why he had not chosen to have something for his defence when there were zombie like things all over the place earlier.

I was worried that he was going to attack some of the zombies. If the show was real, how could they protect the fake zombies from being attacked? I know they told him to stay away because the disease is contagious but what if he had been watching Walking Dead and decided to start stabbing them?

Yeah I thought the same thing, no way I would go out without being weaponized to fight off zombies, those TV shows would have come in handy in that situation :D
Seriously, I don't think they would have allowed him too much freewill in his actions, hence the selection process.


On another note, the specific theme of the show, apocalypse/zombies got me thinking that we are as much being primed by the show to dismiss such events as make believe, we are as much part of the experiment as the person in the show osit.
 
Guardian said:
I think it's totally fake. Steven's body language looked completely wrong to me when he thought he was being chased by zombies, and there were none of the normal signs of adrenalin. His voice never changed. and he didn't even break a sweat. If that had been real (to Steven) , all we would have heard was "beep, beep, beep, beep" over and over again as they censored what was coming out of that boy's mouth. Then there's how he just happened to react exactly as Darren wanted him to at every stage of the game.

I could be wrong, but I think it was just another TV show....a really poorly acted one at that.

It did seem the reality of the situation never dawned on him at all, he seemed half asleep most of the time.

The number of people who are in on the plan is just huge, his house is full of cameras, his laptop and phone are 'hacked'.. Doing this to an unsuspecting member of the public and broadcasting it worldwide must have some ethical issues as well. It is certainly hard to believe.
 
Well, if you listen closely there was some cursing. Not a whole lot, but it was there. I'm pretty sure the British broadcasting rules are lax enough to allow it. And as unethical as the whole thing may be, he probably could have been convinced to sign a contract and release during the audition process that he didn't read thoroughly, allowing for such things to be broadcast. That being said, I think the probability for this being much more "fake" than it appears is fairly high.
 
Considering that it's Derren Brown, I think it's fascinating that anyone thinks it's not fake. Granted I say this without watching it - but - it's television, folks...
 
Derren had to post this video to try to convince people that that guy was not an actor, even though he admits he did some acting while he was in school and that he had a profile on some acting website which he tried to hide once people found it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AqAqhaa0DhE&feature=plcp
 
Tigersoap said:
On another note, the specific theme of the show, apocalypse/zombies got me thinking that we are as much being primed by the show to dismiss such events as make believe, we are as much part of the experiment as the person in the show osit.

I've also been struck by the theme of comets and their bringing along viruses that effect disease resulting in zombies. I find it mind-boggling every time I notice it how the (matrix) control system moves in for damage control, how it steps in continuously to counter every bit of truth which has been made public on the theme of what awaits this world in terms of cosmic house-cleaning. While it does seem to work as a dismissive force for uninformed people, I think it would just as well work as a seeding process for people who're at least in some way receptive/responsive to these levels - just like the dynamic of 'evil does eventually do good despite its contrary intentions'. (Hope that makes sense.)


Alada said:
Nuke said:
Now I wonder : If you don't know that you are going to get hypnotized, would you be still able to fight it ? If the "seduction/suggestion" cames slowly, step by step, would one even realize that he is getting "hacked" ?

But we have already been hypnotized slowly, bit by bit – by life itself. All that we identify with, the things we desire, the things we fear, the programs we run in response. I think it adds up to pretty much the same thing, sleep, a state of hypnosis, the ‘terror of the situation’.

I agree. When watching it, I was especially struck by how well it depicts our collective situation of how thoroughly and easily we've been programmed and are made to believe the themes we've been being fed our entire lives in every aspect of life, and completely identify with what's been written on our hardware. The implications are... somehow beyond adequate words to me.


no-man's-land said:
Another thing is, as others already mentioned, how long this shock will last? We all know that sleep comes in rather quickly again. I am not even sure if he really grasped what was happening. The impression i had was the he constantly looked overcharged, somewhat disconnected from reality. I think, 2 days are way to less to let such a situation really sink in and cause major changes within the person. He constantly lived a shock and then, before real changes took place, he was released.

I had the same impression. Apart from the very probable possibility of it being a complete fake, whenever I switched to the mode of assuming it was for real, the guy struck me as pretty emotionally shallow and disconnected, as you've also pointed out, no-man's-land. And as others have pointed out, the depiction of him having 'developed' a sense of responsibility and caring for others didn't compute with his behaviour. Even if it was real, his behaviour was full of discrepancies regarding these aspects; he was imo still primarily thinking of himself and he had to be pushed and things had to be pointed out to him for him to be seemingly acting along the lines of 'service to others'.

I had the same thoughts concerning the length of the experiment and how the depiction of him having truly changed was ludicrous, given for one, as to what we know about man the machine, and how, even if it was real, there was not the slightest chance of processing what has happened, and integrating it. The relief from the situation came much too fast for anything of substance to sink in.


no-man's-land said:
But the theme also was very interesting. Why a meteor shower combined with a zombie apocalypse? Derren Brown sure have a good sense of humor, but how would Steve react, if this happens for real, now that he gone through a similar shock? Will he even belief it?

I don't think that Derren Brown has a good sense of humor - what could be humorous about manipulating someone and depicting it as beneficial? (Assuming he actually did manipulate the guy for real.)

But it's an interesting question you're posing about how Steve would react to being faced with the reality of experiencing a meteor strike. Don't know the answer, but as I mentioned above, I think some people would be primed to not believe what's happening and not being able to deal with it due to the PTB's specific priming of the masses, but in some people a strong enough seed may have been planted for them to better react to what is, because they have been exposed to the possibility of the reality of such a situation to be happening, and because they had a certain fertile ground/internal set-up for it to take roots.
 
Ok, this is just my opinion so take it just as that - an opinion. When I watched the show I did wonder all the time if the guy Steve was acting or not. He doesn't give much clues because as others have noted, he is kind of shallow in his reactions. But at the end I was inclined to believe it was real precisely because he under-reacted, and because many of his reactions were there but were very subtle. I would expect from an actor to show-off how emotionally charged he was and how upset, etc, and I would expect to hear lots of 'bleeps' trying to convince the public he's for real. But he wasn't. In fact, I found all the other actors (the two guys and the girl) rather fake, with Steve being more convincing.

Some moments that really made me think he was for real were: when he is telling his dad in the car that he heard about meteorites you can tell he is genuinely worried, but very subtly; when he wakes up in the hospital and watches the tv screen, you can see the expression in his eyes and his mouth gasping for air, shocked, but not obviously hysterical; when he records the video for his family he shows some real emotion but again not over the top; when he wakes up in his house and hugs his family.

Also I think we need to consider that for Steve everything happened very fast, within a day or two, so he didn't have any chance to process or question anything. And the very important fact that he was hand-picked from more than a hundred people for sugestibility, among other things.

I think of how people assume that if they were to see a UFO they would go absolutely crazy. But from most of the UFO videos we learn that people don't do that - instead they get nervous or go 'wow', or even start making jokes about it, but I have yet to see anyone go hysterical. It's the dissociative mechanism of the human mind at work in an extreme crisis, preventing the brain from frying, I think. So it doesn't surprise me that this guy Steve (under)reacts the way he does.

I also think that many of the people in the general public who immediately say it is staged say so mainly because they find the idea that they can be controlled and manipulated so easily very uncomfortable. In other words, that we are machines, and because we like to imagine we would not fall for it, we prefer to assume it's staged.

That's just my subjective impression, which of course could be wrong.
 
You're bringing up some very interesting points there, WK, especially this one:

Windmill knight said:
I think of how people assume that if they were to see a UFO they would go absolutely crazy. But from most of the UFO videos we learn that people don't do that - instead they get nervous or go 'wow', or even start making jokes about it, but I have yet to see anyone go hysterical. It's the dissociative mechanism of the human mind at work in an extreme crisis, preventing the brain from frying, I think. So it doesn't surprise me that this guy Steve (under)reacts the way he does.

This point about protective circuits in the brain kicking into gear for maintaining psychological and physiological survival makes sense. Dissociation as a means of dealing with stress and trauma is a basic mechanism of how humans automatically function after all. But to me, the question remains as to how much I'd read into this/project onto it, with regard to the background of what I know about these processes; as in molding what one sees in a given situation into one's own internal concept - making the outside match one's internal material, so to speak.

Windmill knight said:
Some moments that really made me think he was for real were: when he is telling his dad in the car that he heard about meteorites you can tell he is genuinely worried, but very subtly; when he wakes up in the hospital and watches the tv screen, you can see the expression in his eyes and his mouth gasping for air, shocked, but not obviously hysterical; when he records the video for his family he shows some real emotion but again not over the top; when he wakes up in his house and hugs his family.

What made me think he was being genuine was also the situation in the car with his dad, where it seems he's in the state of mind of someone being worried about something/having something working his mind/emotions; as well as one moment when he was running from the zombies, reaching the door of the building, where he was breathing hard and when speaking, the tone of his voice sounded like it carried genuine panic.
 
Aiming said:
This point about protective circuits in the brain kicking into gear for maintaining psychological and physiological survival makes sense. Dissociation as a means of dealing with stress and trauma is a basic mechanism of how humans automatically function after all. But to me, the question remains as to how much I'd read into this/project onto it, with regard to the background of what I know about these processes; as in molding what one sees in a given situation into one's own internal concept - making the outside match one's internal material, so to speak.

Well, for me too, especially now that the forum brought it up. It could be that Steve is after all a bad actor and here I am interpreting his low-key acting as dissociative mechanisms and such, because that's how I imagine I would react. Ultimately it is just my subjective impression/intuition that tells me it's probably real, and my reading abilities have been known to be wrong many times in the past!
 
Watching this now, I'm into part 2, and also have been going back and forth as to whether or not this is totally fake, or totally real. It can be no either way, either Steven is totally fooled into this scenario, or he is also a paid actor.

The initial premise is that he has fallen asleep for 14 days, and awakens into 'the apocalypse.'

But he, and everyone else involved, are totally clean-shaven, and all look like they showered that morning. We never see any of the totally normal things that would occur, like taking a piss, bathing, questioning the situation in any way, wondering what happened, eating food (or at least being slightly concerned about finding some), using a telephone or any means to attempt to contact outside world, etc. etc. There is no evidence of true emotional attachment that would occur in such a crisis, no mourning of the loss of the entire planet, that even such a supposedly dissociated person such as Steven would experience. I think this list could be expanded quite a bit. The lack of 'the little things' is what gives it away imo, and makes the scripting of the situation (including Steven and his controlled reactions) beyond obvious.

To me, there is no question at all that this is entirely fake beyond fake, though it did take about 65 minutes of watching to figure it out. And I'm a pretty dense person lol. :)

I think this is just a grand experiment in getting everyone watching to believe that it is real more than anything else. Does make for compelling fantasy television though, but then again, so does Walking Dead.
 
I found a website that has some pretty convincing evidence that Apocalypse was fake. I love screen shots, I really, really do :)

http://derrenbrownexposed.net/category/apocalypse/
 
Back
Top Bottom