Personally I think menna is aiming some of what he is saying towards me.
menna said:
If one experiences something, is confused, has questions or wants to do research to prepare before an experience, has an interest in theory and wants to network about it thats great however to constantly use this forum to talk about theories one has no experience with and then try to come to conclusion year after year IMO does more harm for the self and others than good.
I'm the only one that I'm aware off who has been vocal about this stuff year after year with seemingly having made no progress i.e. never actually experiencing 'love' as menna put it. Menna was here before and he started a big thread acouple of years ago about being single, but since he has moved on to a newer experience. Personally, when referring to this topic, I think 'love' is the wrong word to use. Maybe simply saying never having experienced a romantic relationship.
To me, 'not experiencing' a romantic relationship is much of an 'emotional experience' than experiencing a romantic one: agreeing with saiedan. The emotions experienced are obviously different, but they are no less powerful and there are lessons learned, even with the seeming external appearance of having made no movement.
In fact, given the programming in society for everyone to be in a romantic relationship in order to achieve fulfillment & happiness, I would say not being in a romantic relationship and still maintaining your faculty of feeling, is even more powerful. It's more powerful because you will feel very powerful feelings, made even stronger as they are against the grain of societal programming. To maintain sanity, function normally and still have an emotional centre where you can relate to other people with empathy and compassion despite this situation further shows that one is not messed up or only diving in intellectual theory without emotions. This is not to say that 'not experiencing' romantic love is also evidence of ones inability to put themselves out there for the sake of experience chasing at a minimum just so that they can say they've overcome that threshold and it's now something they have done. That they have aligned themselves with societal programming and as a result have thus shown themselves to be normally functioning human beings who have balanced centres and can call from experience. There was an
article in SOTT that said 'love' is meant to be easy and if it's not 'easy' you are doing it wrong. I can safely say, I have not dodged any experience where the possibility of a romantic relationship with another human being would fit the criteria of a 'mature relationship'. Any experiences that I have dodged either willingly or denied through the very reason I have inexperience, would have fallen into the 'immature relationship' category. According to that article, love is either a passing game or it's forever. It's either right or wrong. I don't need to 'experience' love as a passing game in order to experience 'love' as forever. A commentator on the article stated that
Sadly, most people would rather be in a bad relationship than in none.
I hazard the guess is so that those people can say they have had the experience. Any experience is better than none at all. If it's there choice, it is and I accept that. I don't walk around feeling negatively about this people who get in and out of romantic relationships, it's their choice and I envy them, despite all the stuff you hear about being in a bad relationship. At least they have the society program behind them and that is one less battle for them to fight. Plus they aren't starved of touch which as we have recently learnt is devastating to humans.
As you said, the world isn't black and white and the range of experience that the universe can create is beyond our measure. However, maybe underlying the message that I read from menna is that maybe it's time to hush up. Do I think it's noise and harmful to talk about it? I think in the wider scheme of things such as global collapse, ptb deception, arrival of wave etc, it's small potatoes, but in individual human terms, this is some of the most powerful experience we can have. It doesn't matter if you are in Iraq, Syria, USA, Japan etc, the connections between people or lack off provide the fodder for individual learning beyond the wider issues that plague our society. War itself is as a result of connection between people, or lack off.