Buddy said:I don't know and the hypothetical questions and scenarios I've been entertaining so far are smoking my brain. Some of this will probably be figured out before it's needed and some of it will probably be figured out as life happens.
The whole topic is a brain smoker, for sure. We've spent hours and hours and I've spent years and years creating mental experiments and letting them run out to see where they go. When you have read enough history, psychology, sociology, etc, you can pretty well plug in most of the variables.
It's somewhat amusing to read some of the comments and to realize that this or that person has not really plumbed the depths of either history or psychology and they have no clue about what they are saying; it's mostly just repeating some favored dictum of this or that "theorist" who purports to have solved the human problem. Well, believe me, I've read all that sort of stuff too. A lot of it falls under Lobaczewski's category of schizoid psychopaths who like to think they have great ideas and have a lot of energy to write them down and propagate them.
It's not just reading the history that has affected me, it's been the process of entering events in our database and seeing the associations and repeats. And here I'm talking about taking history as far back as one can utilizing all available methods.
The main problem that has erupted again and again and again, from as far back as there are written records, is DEBT SLAVERY. When the imbalance between the elite and the masses gets to a certain state, not only does the state collapse from internal conflicts, it seems to bring on other kinds of destruction from the planet or cosmos itself. In some cases, the state makes the slavery tolerable to the masses, so they may go along for a very long time without objecting. But when they begin to suffer a lot for various reasons, including being forced to participate in wars of conquest and thievery, things deteriorate rapidly.
Imagine a group of people arriving at a location after some sort of catastrophe. They set up camp on a ruined city and proceed to apportion out lots of land to everyone equally. So, everyone starts out pretty much equally. And, because of the agricultural nature of the society, things can depend on the land and weather and other variables. If one person has better land, he has more surplus and can live through a period of drought. But the other guy has bad land and a bigger family to feed, so he has to borrow from his neighbor who has surplus. Then, things being as they are, he can never catch up with this debt and he borrows more, and more. Eventually, his land, his wife and children, and then he, himself, go under the ownership of the neighbor who then may repeat the process again and again until he owns a lot of land and plenty of slaves to work it just for his benefit.
That is a simplistic version of how it happens. It happened in Mesopotamia, in Egypt, in Greece, in Rome.
Now, the Mesopotamian civilizations had a way of dealing with this. When a new king ascended the throne, he would declare that all debt slaves be freed and maybe that they could have some of their land back. Or he would transport them to a whole other region where he had killed off all the inhabitants and created a colony. But there was a sort of amnesty that kept things from getting too bad too fast.
Solon was famous for having done something like this.
The early habiru are thought to have been escaped Canaanite debt slaves who banded together as sort of Robin Hood types in the hills of Judea. This deep background is reflected in their legislation about Jubilee years when land that originally belonged to a certain family went back to that family and all debt slaves were freed.
The Romans didn't really have a method to deal with it and we see there the prototype of our own world, though they had declared slaves, nowadays we just have people who "owe their soul to the company store." It's the same thing.
So, this debt slavery problem really weighed on my mind. Moses Finley wrote probably one of the only objective studies of the problem: "Ancient Slavery and Modern Ideology" and there is a LOT of food for thought there.