Question on Suicide

davey72 said:
Hello Opossum.
I think i remember reading somewhere that the c's said that the beaching of whales was usually due to some type of government experiments, and they are just trying to get away from the discomfort that it causes them.
I am sure someone will correct me if i am wrong.
Ah!, I see. That makes sense. So you are saying that the actual death is probably accidental.
I remember reading an article about the beaching of whales and it was actually stated in the article that they committed suicide as a protest against the pollution of their environment. That just goes to show how humans often project feelings and intentions on to animals and other people.
 
Laura said:
Among the saddest cases I have witnessed as a hypnotherapist are the ones where an individual is deeply religious and dies without an inkling of what is on the "other side" and then become lost and wandering souls, imprisoned by their own errors of belief.

Regarding the part where Laura says about religious souls lost wandering where to go, imprisoned in their belief, then I have a question, what about the people who do not even have religious belief, people who are looking for the truth and just have found pieces here, pieces there, lies here and or lies there. How that people know where to go? How do they identify the place as the "correct" one?
 
Hi kakumah,

Welcome to the forum. :) We recommend all new members to post an introduction in the Newbies section telling us a bit about themselves, and how they found their way here. Have a read through that section to get an idea of how others have done it. Thanks.
 
The loved ones of those who have committed suicide often ask themselves "why" for the rest of their lives. That alone may be enough evidence to conclude that the reasons for suicide are complex, variable, and extremely personal.

Have any of you read Notes from the Underground by Dostoevsky? [I don't mean to take this thread off topic -- I'll quickly circle back around.]

In the book, the narrator understands all too clearly the emptiness haunting the lies of society and the blandishments of ego. His insights, however, only make him utterly miserable because he realizes he cannot "do" anything, as Gurdjieff might say. I think Dostoevsky intended to show us a life at the crossroads. Some people reach that point and find a way to begin "the work." Some people consume themselves from within, bit by bit, until they are empty husks. Still others decide they can't take it, and commit suicide as the only escape. An accidental force might be enough to push it one way or another.

There have been more than a few times in my life when I've thought about suicide constantly. I would see a fork and think, "I could stick that through my eye." Or see a bus and think, "I could leap into traffic." Day after day, that was the refrain, for up to a year at a time. The closest I ever came was as an adolescent. I was ready to do it, saw every reason to do it, and the only thing that held me back was the suffering it would cause my Mom.

It struck me that someone mentioned how selfish and solipsistic suicides can seem. It's true! Extrapolating from my own experience, when people get extremely depressed, especially to the point of suicide, they often suffer so intensely that they really can't consider the needs of others. Though thoughts of my Mom's likely suffering may have pulled me from the brink, I nonetheless continued to impose upon her for weeks and months at a time -- demanding her comfort and sympathy, giving back nothing but negativity -- and I knew that and hated myself for it!

Society glibly judges suicides, saying things like: "She got what she wanted," or "He was just too weak for this world" or "I guess she couldn't take the pain."

I don't think it's our job to judge, until we know. And the suicide of another, especially a stranger or estranged friend, is one of those things that will take greatly expanded powers of consciousness to understand. Assuming the C's cosmology is correct, then if the suicide himself needs to work it out in 5D, maybe only 6D can judge.

Dorothy
 
Dorothy Minder said:
It struck me that someone mentioned how selfish and solipsistic suicides can seem. .............
Society glibly judges suicides, saying things like: "She got what she wanted," or "He was just too weak for this world" or "I guess she couldn't take the pain."

I don't think it's our job to judge, until we know. And the suicide of another, especially a stranger or estranged friend, is one of those things that will take greatly expanded powers of consciousness to understand. Assuming the C's cosmology is correct, then if the suicide himself needs to work it out in 5D, maybe only 6D can judge.
Hello Dorothy, Thank you for this very well written and thoughtful post. I was one of the ones who wrote about the selfishness of suicide. I see that I did not make myself clear. It was not meant as a judgement but more as a means of examination of possible motive. It would be fairly easy to make suicide look like an accident so I was talking about the motive one might have for making it obvious that they committed suicide.
I have read Notes from the Underground by Dostoevsky and fully understand your reason for mentioning it.
Extrapolating from my own experience, when people get extremely depressed, especially to the point of suicide, they often suffer so intensely that they really can't consider the needs of others. Though thoughts of my Mom's likely suffering may have pulled me from the brink, I nonetheless continued to impose upon her for weeks and months at a time -- demanding her comfort and sympathy, giving back nothing but negativity -- and I knew that and hated myself for it!
And so did your self hatred cause more suffering and depression which in turn caused more selfish/feeding behaviors? How did you pull yourself out of it? I'm glad you didn't act on your thoughts, Dorothy. I'm happy to see you here trying to help others understand.
:)
Namaste
 
The way i was able to do it was through apathy, and knowing how it would effect those around me, even though i saw a lot of them as the causes of my woes, i couldn't do it. It kept me around long enough to realize that if i did that, then i would just have to do it all over again, and that was the last thing i wanted, so i made a promise to myself at about age 15 that no matter how bad it got, i would stick it out.
That said; I have been found clinically dead a couple times, due to overdoses.(once in a ditch) This just brought on more questions. A friend told me once that he died for 8 1/2 mins,and had near death experience.
He was in a lake of fire, and the grim reaper was his judge,jury and executioner. Told him he was here for a reason, and asked him if he truly wanted to leave this world. He was able to "win" his life back, and 2 angels were sent with him, as his body was no longer viable. They showed him how to rearrange his dna in such a way as to make him able to jump back in. These are the only details he remembers.
 
davey72 said:
The way i was able to do it was through apathy, and knowing how it would effect those around me, even though i saw a lot of them as the causes of my woes, i couldn't do it. It kept me around long enough to realize that if i did that, then i would just have to do it all over again, and that was the last thing i wanted, so i made a promise to myself at about age 15 that no matter how bad it got, i would stick it out.

Yes, I have often believed this would be the case if someone commits suicide in some instances. I'm glad you stuck it out.

That said; I have been found clinically dead a couple times, due to overdoses.(once in a ditch) This just brought on more questions. A friend told me once that he died for 8 1/2 mins,and had near death experience.
He was in a lake of fire, and the grim reaper was his judge,jury and executioner. Told him he was here for a reason, and asked him if he truly wanted to leave this world. He was able to "win" his life back, and 2 angels were sent with him, as his body was no longer viable. They showed him how to rearrange his dna in such a way as to make him able to jump back in. These are the only details he remembers.

That is very interesting Davey72. I have had a somewhat similar experience and have never heard this discussed before. In fact, I sometimes imagine I died somewhere else and ended up here!!!
As Data once said in another thread,(paraphrased)"jumping off a building is a very mechanical action", which made me realize that most suicides are just that. An awake, conscious person would be unlikely to do it. There is no judgement intended by this statement except an assessment of possible state of mind or acting from false personality. I hope this makes sense.
 
And so did your self hatred cause more suffering and depression which in turn caused more selfish/feeding behaviors? How did you pull yourself out of it? I'm glad you didn't act on your thoughts, Dorothy. I'm happy to see you here trying to help others understand.

You describe the vicious cycle very aptly. Answering the second part of your question is harder so I'll approach it from a different angle to begin.

The entry "Centers, Playing Card Analogy" in the Cassiopedia says this: "Committing suicide is the ultimate in identification and subjective self-absorption." I think that's right. A budding psychopath tries to extend his domination and subjugate other consciousnesses, so his identity is necessarily in flux -- in other words, he knows it is limited and seeks to expand it. A suicide, on the other hand, carves out a discrete identity "me" and sees no possibility of meaningful intercourse with the outside world.

Like Davey described, I think empathy is the only thing that kept me from going through with it. And empathy, at base, is an extension of identity. It's a recognition of inter-being. So when I decided that I could never cause my Mom such suffering, I turned a corner by admitting some permeability in my sense of self.

As Data once said in another thread,(paraphrased)"jumping off a building is a very mechanical action", which made me realize that most suicides are just that. An awake, conscious person would be unlikely to do it. There is no judgement intended by this statement except an assessment of possible state of mind or acting from false personality. I hope this makes sense.

It does make sense, and I think you and Data are correct. The more conscious we become, the more we see the interconnectedness and dynamism of things, and the more we identify with all aspects of our experience without differentiating between inner and outer, me and you. Only mechanical thought processes can maintain a discrete sense of self (or self-loathing). That said, someone who is very depressed can get caught in mechanical thought processes that include very penetrating insights.

For example: Imagine a woman in her 50s who realizes in a short period that she's wasted her life in careerism and that the money never satisfied; that for decades she has furthered the agenda of a functionally psychopathic corporation; that her husband leeches her money and energy and only pretends to love her; that the "morals" and "culture" of society are a pack of lies; and that, finally, she was an awful mother to her children, now grown and estranged from her.

Those are real insights that many people never have. Such insights have the potential to change the entire course of a person's life, for the better! And it may even be necessary for that person to dwell on those insights for a period of weeks or months, simply so they don't brush them under the rug -- so that, seeing the darkness for what it is, they can awake to themselves. But in the interval between the dark and light unveilings, there is tremendous suffering. If that suffering feeds on itself mechanically, if the person can't break the cycle of depression and self-loathing, it can lead to suicide.

Here we might also consider the idea of psychic attack. Someone who awakes to the nastiness of everyday life is, of course, a potential danger to the people, institutions, and thought patterns that cultivate that nastiness. I imagine a fair number of people going through serious depressive episodes have "heard" certain thoughts or thought patterns repeating over and over in their minds, and said to themselves, "Where is this coming from?" or "I don't think like that!" I suspect that sometimes these mechanical thought loops come from "outside." At the same time, though, these sorts of attacks probably require the victim to be in a certain state of mind -- namely, depression -- to resonate.

So, winding up, if the person cobbles together enough consciousness to identify beyond themselves, to empathize, maybe even to begin the work, then they can raise their vibration level and pull themselves out. But, the more individual the effort, the more difficult. It's hard to identify beyond yourself when you don't see anything positive to identify with. I had my Mom. Everyone needs someone.

Dorothy
 
Another awesome post Dorothy! You had your mom and now, someone has you, even if you haven't met them yet. :) What you said about an outside source (voice) is right on target but don't tell that to most shrinks unless you want a label (schizophrenic) tattooed on your forehead. :rockon:
 
Thanks! There are so many important conversations on this board. For now, I want to limit myself to the ones where I feel confident I can contribute, and to put time and effort into each post.

What goes for shrinks, goes for anyone -- it helps to understand one's audience. :)

Take care!
 
Thanks, to all for your insights on suicide.

It has stirred memories of my first experience of someone I knew who took their own life. I was about 14 at the time, 1961.

My Uncles wife probably had chemical imbalances, she was always morose and sad. I remember, when we were watching western movies on TV and some one would get shot she would get very upset, even cry. Assurances that they were just actors didn't console her. She was eventually diagnosed as being a schizophrenic.

My Uncle was a heavy drinker at the time. So she got little empathy and support at home. When she had a particularly bad episode they would take her to the local mental hospital for electric shock treatments. It must have been horrifying for her.

They lived in an older house. I remember that the kitchen she spent much of her day in was painted black. Who would paint a kitchen black?

One day she put on her Sunday best clothes and hung herself from a stairwell. Her son found her when he came home for lunch. After, her son, my cousin moved in with my Aunts parents. He never spoke to my Uncle again.

Her act was probably mechanical, she knew of no other way to escape her situation.

I hope she was able to find help where she has gone.

Sorry, for the sad story. I guess the sadness of the time still lives in me at some level. This occurred about 6 months after my dad died. The imprint of those times is with me still.

Mac
 
[quote author=Mac]

They lived in an older house. I remember that the kitchen she spent much of her day in was painted black.Who would paint a kitchen black? [/quote]
Who painted it black?
One day she put on her Sunday best clothes and hung herself from a stairwell. Her son found her when he came home for lunch. After, her son, my cousin moved in with my Aunts parents. He never spoke to my Uncle again.

Her act was probably mechanical, she knew of no other way to escape her situation
yes, of course, otherwise how could she have done something that would be so traumatic for her son, to come home and find her that way.

I hope she was able to find help where she has gone.

Sorry, for the sad story. I guess the sadness of the time still lives in me at some level. This occurred about 6 months after my dad died. The imprint of those times is with me still.
I am sorry for your trauma at such a young age and glad you have found people here you feel comfortable sharing your memories with.

namaste
 
davey72 said:
opossum said:
Don't whales sometimes commit suicide by beaching themselves? Of course it's impossible to know the reason or to assign an intention to their actions, however they are extremely intelligent animals. It seems that the most common "reason" for suicide is to end unbearable pain, psychological or physical. Suicide can be carried out by the mind causing the body to die of natural causes or to be involved in an accident so many who apparently take their own life are possibly suspect as having some underlying STS influence or intention as it would be easy for any remotely intelligent person to make it look like an accident. OSISI.

*edited to add something- I think if someone commits suicide because of extreme pressure from an outside source or an attached entity it would be considered murder. Gives attached entities something to think about in that they are continuing to accrue Karma until they go home!:/
Hello Opossum.
I think i remember reading somewhere that the c's said that the beaching of whales was usually due to some type of government experiments, and they are just trying to get away from the discomfort that it causes them.
I am sure someone will correct me if i am wrong.


postmortems on beached whales have revealed damage to their auditory canals, which would be very painful, and make it difficult to communicate, navigate, and dive deep which they frequently do when feeding. There are also reports that these beaching events occur when submarines have been testing sonar arrays.
 
opossum said:
[quote author=Mac]

They lived in an older house. I remember that the kitchen she spent much of her day in was painted black.Who would paint a kitchen black?
Who painted it black?
[/quote]

It was probably that way when they moved in. My Uncle was a heavy drinker then and for years after. I doubt that he would have had the ambition to paint the kitchen.

I hope she was able to find help where she has gone.

Sorry, for the sad story. I guess the sadness of the time still lives in me at some level. This occurred about 6 months after my dad died. The imprint of those times is with me still.
I am sorry for your trauma at such a young age and glad you have found people here you feel comfortable sharing your memories with.

namaste

Yes it is good to bring these things to the surface. I'm sure there is "poor me" lurking there. Like repressed anger at having to go through it all.

I've know a few other people who have killed themselves. It seemed to me to be a very selfish act, causing grief and turmoil for others. Maybe it isn't so much selfish as robotic.

Mac

Moderator: Fixed quotes
 

Trending content

Back
Top Bottom