Hi realitybugll, fwiw I got some thoughts by reading your post that I'd like to share:
realitybugll said:
When I do the pipe breathing lying down instead of sitting or standing it is quite a different experience for me. First what is interesting is that sometimes my stomach with get extremely tingly all over, I have not read anyone describe that physical symptom. It does not happen ever when I sit and do the pipe breathing, only when I am laying down. Also something I have noticed: When I am holding the air for 3 counts and then breathing it out for 9 counts it is a lot more "awkward" to do while laying down.
It seems to be that for some people doing breathing exercises while sitting is easier, when as for some people it is easier to do them while lying down. I myself find it a bit easier to do e.g. the EE program lying down, but I know from experience that it is good for me to do these things sitting too; doing e.g. the EE while sitting corresponds better to the "real life" or "every day" situations. The EE is beneficial in many ways, but one of the many benefits, as I see it, is that one learns to "keep the breathing down" (deep diaphragmatic breathing) even while standing, walking or sitting and going on with our every day life. This should be the way nature has "planned" it, but for many reasons we have trouble doing it. And our breathing tends to go wrong especially when stressful and critical situations arise (this probably is to some amount natural too, cf. fight or flight response). In those situations it is good to have training in breathing and IMO doing breathing exercises lying down gives poorer preparation for these moments. Having said that, there is in my opinion benefits in doing breathing exercises lying down too, like being able to relax more easily. It can also be easier to go "deeper" while lying down, and from what you are describing (awkward feeling, tingling) this might be the difference you are sensing.
What I'm getting at, is that IMO you really should choose the position that works best for you. If EE works better for you while sitting, then do it that way - that sounds good. I see that "configuration" as more beneficial than the other way around (things working better while lying down). On the other hand, if you can successfully do the EE while sitting there most probably shouldn't be any problems at all doing it while lying down, because breathing works in my experience always more smoothly lying down. For possible explanations why this isn't happening for you see below.
When I am sitting up, the air for the most part naturally rests in my stomach with some in my chest and I am able to fluidly breath it out. When laying down however as soon as a stop breathing in air, my chest will often inflate hugely and my stomach deflate unless I keep the air "held" in my stomach. I countered this problem by continue to breath in on the pause for 3 counts even though my air capacity is full. If a lot of air does get into my chest I have to empty my stomach and then my chest and I actually need a half second pause to be able to achieve this.
Okay, it sounds to me that for some reason you are breathing exclusively into the chest (the diaphragm doesn't descend properly), and maybe doing even reversed breathing (the belly gets sucked in when breathing in). When you are sitting gravity will assist with keeping the breath low, when you are lying down you don't get this "help".
Now, for whatever the reason you are doing upper breathing or even reversed breathing while lying down I would suggest a few things:
-One reason that comes to my mind is that your lower back is arched upwards and tense. Is there a space between your lower back and the bed you are lying on? You should choose a bed that supports your back in the right way. If you lie on a harder platform, e.g. on the floor, you can use a pillow under your knees. This will help you get the lower back "glued" to the floor which is critical for relaxed lower breathing. You can also bend your knees, lifting the knees upward. This will do the same as with the pillow, only more.
- Do the "book thing", e.g. place a heavy book on your belly and concentrate on getting that book to lift up every time you inhale. Be careful not to try to breathe in TOO MUCH (it sound to me that you might be doing this). It is always better to breathe a little air in the right place, than breath with full capacity in the wrong place (chest). And if you're new to this, breathing with full capacity with complete descending of the diaphragm is not possible - it takes time to make this happen! So, don't try to inhale with "full jets" the whole time that Laura keeps counting. Just breathe that amount that you feel the diaphragm responses to; if you feel that the d. doesn't go any lower don't compensate by changing to upper breath. I believe that you can feel when you "let the anchor go" (the diaphragm pops up even though you keep breathing in).
- I feel it's easier to not use a pillow (under my head) when doing breathing exercises lying down. It is easy for the throat (pipe) to get bent too much when using a big pillow, hence making it more difficult to the breathing apparatus to function