From sitting:
Assuming you've read all of the transcript material, what kind of feelings & emotions does it engender in your being?
Yes, I have read all the scripts. Emotions?...a bit of disgust i think, and some sadness for those who think it can make a difference. Feelings, see below.
... and I'm in full agreement, that hope is passive...a feeling of "waiting to be served".
From Joe:
You should probably define what you mean by the word, before suggesting its elimination.
Joe, I thought the above was fairly clear as a definition....don't know what more to say.. but I'll try.
There is quite a difference between hope and understanding the facts, then holding justified optimism. Hope is magical thinking..
I understand that what Bagent and Trudell were talking about was O'bummers use of the word in his campaign....but "Magical thinking" is close to my feelings about it in a general, simple way.
If the definition of "hope" is justified optimism....well, then I'm completely wrong.
I'm most likely "coloring" it with my own bad(?) attitude about it, like i so often do with some things... my bad attitude stems from the "magical thinking" definition, the one that politicians and religious types use too much that i was referring to. (please read the linked article, if you have the time)
If, on the other hand, you "plan for the worst and hope for the best", then hope is OK, being there is nothing left you can
do.....even then, it still seems to me to be useless yearning. What i see in the people who overuse the word is not enough doing....almost as if hope is a substitute for doing all that can be done.
It's been a while since i read your first post Joe, and i think maybe you were talking about the "plan for the worst, hope for the best kind"...so I'll go back and read it again....
One other thing that is the most likely real culprit of my attitude towards it is this; that I feel I've completely lost all hope of having any ability to fix my own petty little personal problems, let alone doing things that advance me toward goals i wish to accomplish. I've become hopeless. G was right, you can't do it yourself. That idea has always bothered me; what kind of "loving" God would make a creature that could not find his way back to him on his own?...but I know, I know...he didn't make just one creature...he made many, and its become painfully obvious to me now that we need each others help. ( Please excuse the male "god" ref's...it's an old thought from when i still believed) ....sorry, i'm going off track..
Anyway, I may be projecting my own hopelessness onto the word itself... and maybe Trudell and Bagent were too?..I don't know...
Thanks, Dave