Re: Ketogenic Diet - Path To Transformation?
Foxx said:
chaps23, it's a little strange to me that you're so identified with this site being a good resource when it's simply not. It has some truth in it, but then misses the picture by a wide margin and doesn't seem to actually provide anything useful to the research here nor would it be helpful to a lay person who hasn't done all the research here.
It also makes me wonder about your knowledge of the diet, considering the parts you've excerpted and that you seem to be missing the point that many things have been quite conclusively determined to be unhealthy. No amount of research is going to come back and suddenly result in "oh, trans fats are actually good" or "the benefits of soy suddenly outweigh all the huge negative health effects"--not going to happen.
Have you read the entire Life Without Bread and Ketogenic Diet threads, along with Primal Body, Primal Mind and any of the other reading materials?
Hi Foxx, Anart,
Apologies for wasting your time. I think Foxx you miss understood (likely due to my poor writing skills) what I was getting at, when I said
I'm sure down the track we too will find things we have discussed that turned out to be all wrong.
I was simply stating that we have made similar mistakes to what she/ the Author is doing now, I also admited that the site had lots of these "errors" on it and advised that there would need to be amendments. To further add especially before attempting the receipe section but some of them look so yummy.... I am fully aware of the dangers these products cause and I was in no way endorsing them.
Foxx, did I ever endorse Soy or Trans Fats? If so please state where? I do sometimes type with out thinking but I highly doubt I would do that. And is there anything I said in particular or directly that has made you doubt my knowlege of the Keto Diet? Especially since I gave those warnings at the beginning of the post then further more on my next post? I do however, apologise if that was the impression I gave.
Anart, yes your right it is all in this thread but when I go to look for something it takes me two & half hours to find it on here. I loved the convieninece the site offered but since this whole forum is dedicated to weeding out the bull&^%$ I do truly understand what it was I did wrong. I have forever been sifting through various webpages then cross checking data here/elsewhere and I see that thats not the way things are done here.
anart said:
chaps23 said:
Never the less my truth searching goes on!
Try
reading and understanding the entire ketogenic diet thread - including the referenced papers. The information is right there, for goodness sake.
I was just saying truth searching/learning in general (like all life are consistantly doing everyday), reading is easy, but understanding not so easy. Thanks for your concern I have always had trouble absorbing information that I read I'm an auditive learner.
Megan said:
I'm sorry I wasn't clearer when I replied. I did see your other comments about the website but, as it turned out, I only had time to write some general comments of my own because of something else that came up unexpectedly at home.
This has been discussed before, I think, but what we are doing here is different from what people in general are doing with low-carb/KD, and there is nothing particularly simple about it, starting with the need to read these topics (LWB & KD) in their entirety. "Simple" websites presenting potentially misleading, confusing, and contradictory information aren't any help here, I don't think.
Sometimes it can be worth it to weed out the bad information, if there is a core of good material that surpasses what is available elsewhere. I think that has been the case with Phinney & Volek's work, even though when you look at their specific food recommendations some of it is garbage. One of them actually discovered empirically how bad soybean oil was, when it affected his human experiments (the subjects avoided the food that contained it, because they didn't feel right after eating it!), and yet I don't think they advise strictly avoiding vegetable oils even now (I would have to check to be sure).
Hi Again Megan,
I understand completely so dont stress, I dont have/ cant afford the internet at home so I do all my stuff at work and am forever being interupted.
I know what we are doing here is different, I just thought there was stuff on there worth reading/sifting through. You and Anart are definately correct in saying the highlighted text, especially the
potentialy misleading information when lots is already available here. I dont know why alarm bells didn't ring while I was doing it. The last thing I want to do here is be responcible for unintentionally guiding somebody down the wrong track, I wouldn't forgive myself.
Perhaps the next time I feel neccesary to share information I should spend much more time doing the "Sifting" before hand. Unfortunately due to restrictions on the net at work I can not view alot of the data posted here on this site SOTT/YouTube even the Quantum Future site all blocked! :( so I try to find similar information so that I can try to contribute to this awesome group in a positive way. Perhaps I'm going about all this wrong....
Anyway enough wasting everybodies time thanks again guys. I will endevor to improve as always,
Warm Regards,
Brent.