henry
The Cosmic Force
Lurking may be necessary for some people to build the confidence they need to participate. As you say, when we first arrive, we might perceive some of the remarks to be quite harsh. We can react to that badly as it can trigger many programmes within us. We are not accustomed to hearing these things about us, and in the past when people were direct and blunt and harsh, it was often meant to hurt.
"Well, I only said the truth!" is often the justification.
There is a passage in ISOTM where Gurdjieff talks about this kind of 'sincerity':
That is by and large what we know of 'sincerity' in the world, among our 'friends', with our family.
So I think it is normal that some people need time to get the temperature of the water and see by the actions of the members here that this, perhaps at first glance, bluntness, is in fact the highest form of sincerity towards each other.
"Well, I only said the truth!" is often the justification.
There is a passage in ISOTM where Gurdjieff talks about this kind of 'sincerity':
The opposite of internal considering and what is in part a means of fighting against it is external considering. External considering is based upon an entirely different relationship towards people than internal considering. It is adaptation towards people, to their understanding, to their requirements. By considering externally a man does that which makes life easy for other people and for himself. External considering requires a knowledge of men, an understanding of their tastes, habits, and prejudices. At the same time external considering requires a great power over oneself, a great control over oneself. Very often a man desires sincerely to express or somehow or other show to another man what he really thinks of him or feels about him. And if he is a weak man he will of course give way to this desire and afterwards justify himself and say that he did not want to lie, did not want to pretend, he wanted to be sincere. Then he convinces himself that it was the other man's fault. He really wanted to consider him, even to give way to him, not to quarrel, and so on. But the other man did not at all want to consider him so that nothing could be done with him.
That is by and large what we know of 'sincerity' in the world, among our 'friends', with our family.
So I think it is normal that some people need time to get the temperature of the water and see by the actions of the members here that this, perhaps at first glance, bluntness, is in fact the highest form of sincerity towards each other.