Wisteria
Jedi
Aragorn said:I could be wrong, but it sounds like you might not be "filling up from the bottom". That is, your expansion with the inhale goes too quickly to the upper parts of the body, without filling the "root" or lower part first. Holding the air with the chest (upper part) without having first filled the "basement" will cause a feeling of panic. Think of it as filling up a glass of wine (with water!): you start at the bottom, then slowly fill it up. The idea of the hold is not to do it only with your chest or whole ribcage. Instead, the diaphragm plays a crucial role: you can think of it as a beach ball that you are pressing under the water - the 'hold' is the feeling of keeping it under water, despite the tendency for it to bounce back up on the surface. When you master this, you can incorporate more of the lower ribs, perhaps even sternum. But always start by feeling the diaphragm going as low as possible - one teacher told me, that when you do it properly, it feels as your hips are expanding to the sides!
Good luck, and let us know how it goes. :)
Thanks for your feedback Aragorn. I don't think that's the problem though. I've been a (classically and tonally trained) singer for 24 years and am very practiced with the art of diaphragm breathing. If anything, I have less feelings of panic when I do the second (chest) and third (upper) stages. I think this may be because there might be a little residual air still in my diaphragm so I don't feel like I'm so starved for oxygen.
I tried holding my own count instead of going by Laura's, and that worked really well. I think that provided I don't push myself too hard too fast, I'll be able to work my way up to the real count soon enough. :)




May you continue to change the lives of many around the world ;) 

And the awareness about breathing for stress reduction is finally catching on, Doctors are now recommending it to patients, for all sorts of health issues!