mcb
The Living Force
I very much agree. I can see huge differences from one person diagnosed with a high-functioning form of Autism to the next, and the DSM-5 proposal seeks to "blur" things even more. I would call that "deliberate."Laura said:...That's my point. On the one hand, there are experts saying that Asperger's is just a mild form of psychopathy (same about Autism) and on the other hand, there are people with this "diagnosis" who are clearly NOT psychopathic. So, my guess is that it is a deliberate blurring of the lines kind of like mixing up the diagnoses of ASPD and psychopathy. They are all just relying on external behaviors, NOT on what is inside. There can be VASTLY different reasons for external behaviors and this mode of diagnosing people is just Medieval! A person falls on the floor foaming at the mouth and they are diagnosed as demon possessed. In fact, they could be having 1) an epileptic seizure; 2) a stroke; 3) hydrophobia; 4) anything else.
So, basically, I would rather reject the Autism/Asperger's diagnoses unless and until some work is done on figuring out what is going on inside the person. Otherwise, they are going to take this label and do some very ugly things with it.
The thing I have noticed the most is the lack of "experiencers" among those doing the diagnosing. I mentioned before that I had a friend my age, for years, that was HFA and far more impaired than I. I spent months learning to communicate with him (he was almost incomprehensible to the untrained ear) before I could have any clear idea of what his strengths and limitations were. I don't think anyone else ever did that.
It was a sad situation where I found that he had much potential for development relative to where he was, and he very much wanted to develop, but he was still living at home (in his 50s) and his parents stood in the way of his doing almost anything. THEY had diagnosed him as "hopeless" and were determined to be right, I guess.
In the transsexual (TS) community to which I also belong the story is a little different because there are significant numbers of TSs that are MDs. With the autistic spectrum, the obstacles to to doing that are higher. For me, getting my B.S. degree was so frustrating (it took 10 years) that I never wanted to go back to school again.
Ultimately, though, the problem is that the medical system is not especially concerned about finding the root causes. It's about making money.