You're not an orphan Benjamin, was also surprised by how strongly the Hu song reminded me of something Nordic, as opposed to Mongolian!
Felt like it wouldn't have been out of place on the soundtrack to 'Vikings' actually
You actually brought up an interesting thought for me. The Hu popularize throat singing using the framework of rock music (similar to what A Tribe Called Red did with Native American music (eg:
Stadium Pow Wow), but this is a bit different and not quite where I'm going. In the cases of Heilung (
my post) and your post from 'Vikings', it makes me wonder if the music (the 'feeling' is what I'm getting at) really sounded that way. I understand that these examples are an interpretation obviously, but it's the interpretation that's my sticking point.
Why does "ancient music" (at least in these two cases) 'feel' this way. Do we expect this is the way it was? Is this what people want the music to sound like? I'll give an example:
Bookjunkie posted a comment on the Heilung video saying: "You know what's wrong with today's society? No one drinks out of the skulls of their enemies anymore..."
The 1 year old comment received more then 20K likes, the most I've seen any comment to get there, as well as the most replies.
For comparison, the 2nd most liked comment is at least 2 years old, receiving more then 17K likes, is from Johnathan Bravo (Johnathan Jones) saying: "Only A.D. 490's kids will remember this."
The poster 'Bookjunkie' shows his/her mind (that is, if they were being serious) about conquest and subsequently wanting to drink out of skulls of enemies believing that this will solve all of life's problems. But still, this music for that person inspires such thoughts even if the music is going in a totally different direction (did Bookjunki even understand the lyrics?). The music seems to inspire a certain version (?) of history, and I wonder if it is accurate or if "we" just want it to be. (This idea is a bit messy for me to put into words. Sorry if it's unclear.)
As a lighter footnote there are many silly comments to the Heilung video but I liked this one from AlbinoBadGuy: "I watched this one night with me cat sitting next to me. In the morning, my cat brought me 3 squirrels, 2 birds and a Deer."