Thank you Joe, for sharing your horror experience. I understand that you contacted Dr. Haskell and thought it would be interesting to hear what Dr. Brownstein would have to say about it. I still have the feeling that he has more experience with iodine/iodide supplementation and as he states in the book, he advises detox with saltwater and Vit C apart from additional minrals/Vitamins.
For me, the video by Dr. Haskell also came across as a little bit of a sales thing. His product Iodoplus does have its flaws as the iodine/iodide(3mg) is combined with 200 mcg og Selenium. I see that as a little dangerous as if someone buys it and want to get more iodine/iodide, they also up the dosis of Selenium which is already pretty much at the max limit.
Did such a high dosis of Selenium not ring an alarm bell with Dr. Haskell and did he not consider that the reaction of that person, which it took a month to recover from could be due to a massive overdose of Selenium?
Dr. Haskell in his video attacks the claim about the iodine intake of 12.5 mg saying that there are different types of kelp and then further cites an article in the journal Thyroid Research from 2011, which speculates that the Japanese intake of iodine/iodide is between 1-3mg per day.
Dr. Abraham and Dr. Brownstein have disputed these counter attacks regarding Japanese iodine intake:
So I think it is valid to ask why the report in the journal of Thyroid Research should be taken as a gospel as Dr. Haskell seems to do. Thyroid Research is after all a mainstream site, that thinks that iodine deficiency is pretty much eradicated according to their editor in chief:
Dr. Haskell mentions in the video two cases and they are frankly not convincing as casestudies. The first case is a woman who Dr. Haskell had put on 12.5mg of iodine/iodide and then after 3 months she shows quite elevated levels of TSH. Well, Dr. Brownstein did mention that this would happen and that it would settle down again after 3-6 months. Dr. Haskell instead says that though the woman hadn't developed Hashimoto disease, she was at risk. Ok, big deal, but is there really a big risk if she is supervised by a doctor?
The second case is a 32 year old man who self experimented for two months with 50mg of iodine/iodide and ran into trouble. He suffered loss of weight and an elevated heart rate. Sorry but I find that a week argument for not to take higher dosis of iodine. The reason is that this guy acted without much knowledge, if any. No saltwater, no Vit C, no selenium, no additional support minerals/vitamins. Going blind into something is calling for disaster. One can debunk anything by citing some peoples self-experimentations without knowledge.
I just felt the need to make a couple of comments to the Haskell video, as it irked me when I first saw it. And I do think the dangers can be quite real of having bad experiences due to too much selenium by taking more than 1 pill of Iodoral.
Though I think it is a good idea to be prudent about iodine/iodide intake, I also think it is good not to throw the baby out with the bath water. So gather information, detox with saltwater even before starting and then start slowly and adjust based on body responses. And a thank you to Gaby for posting all this information about iodine, the first page especially of this thread is packed full of interesting studies.
For me, the video by Dr. Haskell also came across as a little bit of a sales thing. His product Iodoplus does have its flaws as the iodine/iodide(3mg) is combined with 200 mcg og Selenium. I see that as a little dangerous as if someone buys it and want to get more iodine/iodide, they also up the dosis of Selenium which is already pretty much at the max limit.
So somebody took 75 mg of iodoplus, the product that Dr. Haskell sells, which amounts to 25 pills, which means that the person also received a dosis of 25 times 200mcg of Selenium or 5000mcg!!!I emailed that Dr. Haskell guy, and he suggested it was "all likely due to hyperthyroid from over stimulating tsh production". He also said "I remember this happening when a person was on 75mg of iodoplus but it took a month for him to come down so you are lucky with having recovered so quickly."
Did such a high dosis of Selenium not ring an alarm bell with Dr. Haskell and did he not consider that the reaction of that person, which it took a month to recover from could be due to a massive overdose of Selenium?
Dr. Haskell in his video attacks the claim about the iodine intake of 12.5 mg saying that there are different types of kelp and then further cites an article in the journal Thyroid Research from 2011, which speculates that the Japanese intake of iodine/iodide is between 1-3mg per day.
Dr. Abraham and Dr. Brownstein have disputed these counter attacks regarding Japanese iodine intake:
http://www.westonaprice.org/modern-diseases/the-great-iodine-debate/ said:Subsequent counter arguments by Drs Abraham and Brownstein and rebuttals by Dr. Gaby focused on the amount of iodine in the Japanese diet and the safety of ingesting large amounts. An important point made by Abraham and Brownstein is that the requirement for iodine depends on the goitrogen load. Bromine, now very prevelant in the food supply, is a goitrogen, and may increase our need for iodine. They also claim that many of the toxic effects reported in the literature were due to radioactive forms of iodine. Finally, they dispute the assertion that the values of iodine in seaweed consumed by the Japanese were computed in dry weight. “The average daily intake of iodine by mainland Japanese in 1963 was 13.8 mg, based on information supplied by the Japanese Ministry of Health, which used only dry weight in their calculations, confirmed by a phone interview of one of us (GEA) on June 21, 2005, with officials of this organization.”26
So I think it is valid to ask why the report in the journal of Thyroid Research should be taken as a gospel as Dr. Haskell seems to do. Thyroid Research is after all a mainstream site, that thinks that iodine deficiency is pretty much eradicated according to their editor in chief:
Are the disorders from iodine deficiency really declining around the world or it is just that various thyroid disorders are considered as being genetic or due not to a lack of iodine deficiency. If one does not think that iodine deficiency plays a key role in Hashimoto disease or in Graves disease or even in breast cancers and a host of other diseases, then one can say that all is well in the world and keep promoting thyroid drugs and chemotherapy etc._http://www.thyroidresearchjournal.com/ said:Thyroid Research is developing particularly rapidly. There is an increase in thyroid cancer treatment options, not only surgery and radioactive iodine but also using a new generation of drugs - inhibitors of tyrosine kinases. There has been a rapid development of genetics in relation to both carcinogenesis in the thyroid, and as regards predisposition to autoimmune thyroid diseases. Gradually, in various countries around the world iodine deficiency disorders are becoming rarer; they are eliminated as a result of effective iodine prophylaxis."
Prof. Andrzej Lewinski
Editor-in-Chief
Thyroid Research
President of Polish Thyroid Association
Dr. Haskell mentions in the video two cases and they are frankly not convincing as casestudies. The first case is a woman who Dr. Haskell had put on 12.5mg of iodine/iodide and then after 3 months she shows quite elevated levels of TSH. Well, Dr. Brownstein did mention that this would happen and that it would settle down again after 3-6 months. Dr. Haskell instead says that though the woman hadn't developed Hashimoto disease, she was at risk. Ok, big deal, but is there really a big risk if she is supervised by a doctor?
The second case is a 32 year old man who self experimented for two months with 50mg of iodine/iodide and ran into trouble. He suffered loss of weight and an elevated heart rate. Sorry but I find that a week argument for not to take higher dosis of iodine. The reason is that this guy acted without much knowledge, if any. No saltwater, no Vit C, no selenium, no additional support minerals/vitamins. Going blind into something is calling for disaster. One can debunk anything by citing some peoples self-experimentations without knowledge.
I just felt the need to make a couple of comments to the Haskell video, as it irked me when I first saw it. And I do think the dangers can be quite real of having bad experiences due to too much selenium by taking more than 1 pill of Iodoral.
Though I think it is a good idea to be prudent about iodine/iodide intake, I also think it is good not to throw the baby out with the bath water. So gather information, detox with saltwater even before starting and then start slowly and adjust based on body responses. And a thank you to Gaby for posting all this information about iodine, the first page especially of this thread is packed full of interesting studies.